In his memoir, Artful Tom, Thomas Hoving, former director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art described Harry Sperling as his favorite "dealer-smuggler".
**********
(“Besides Harry Sperling another of my favorite dealer-smugglers was John J. Klejman.”
**********
In 2007, the Holocaust Claims Processing Office (HCPO) announced the restitution by the Metropolitan Museum of art of a drawing entitled Interior of a Church that had been looted from Holocaust victim Arthur Feldmann by Nazis in 1939.
The provenance of the looted drawing was described as follows:
**********
"The Museum received the drawing as a bequest from Mr. Sperling in 1975 and was unaware of its connection to Dr. Feldmann or that it was looted during the Holocaust. Mr. Sperling acquired the drawing from P. and D. Colnaghi and Co., Ltd. in London in 1954."
(https://web.archive.org/web/20120119064715/http://www.dfs.ny.gov/consumer/holocaust/hcpopr071030.htm )
**********
Provenance researchers, art law lawyers, criminal investigators, journalists and museum officials might imagine that the combination of a clearly looted artwork and the declaration by the museum's director that the donor was a "dealer-smuggler" would trigger an investigation into the other artworks acquired from the same person -- especially those with provenance gaps for the Nazi years.
But, sadly, this did not happen.
So, here, for those interested, we publish the provenances of the artworks currently in the Metropolitan Museum of Art that have a connection to Sperling. Either a direct connection as part of Harry Sperling's generous bequest to the museum. Or as part of the acquisitions financed by the "Sperling Fund".
The dataset contains 265 artworks donated by the Sperling Bequest and 611 artworks acquired via the Sperling FUND. Less than 10 of these have clear provenances for the Nazi years.
Certain patterns leap out at even the most casual viewer. We will examine these later.
The pivot table below shows:
1) Whether the artwork came to the Metropolitan via Harry Sperling's bequest or via financing through the Sperling Fund
2) The provenance text published by the Metropolitan Museum between 2024 and 2026.
3) The number of artworks with the exact same provenance text published by the museum
Sperling MASTER DATASET Bequest/FUND Pivot Table on Provenance
| SELECTION (Sperling Bequest or Sperling Fund) | PROVENANCE (published by Metropolitan Museum of Art 2024-6) | COUNTA of Object ID |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Harry G. Sperling | 114 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Sotheby's, LondonJuly 8, 1964, part of no. 40(sold as "Italian 17th century"); Harry G. Sperling | 2 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Sir Joshua Reynolds (British); Harry G. Sperling | 2 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | John Thane (British); Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); William Esdaile (British); Christie's, London, June 18, 1840, part of lot 113 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); A. E. Williamson; Sotheby's, London, June 21, 1950, part of lot 19 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); sale, Christie's, London, November, 30, 1965, part of lot 13; Harry G. Sperling | 2 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Giuseppe Vallardi (Italian); Harry G. Sperling | 2 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Charles Eggimann (Swiss); Harry G. Sperling | 2 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Alvin Beaumont; Wynne R.H. Jeudwine (British); Harry G. Sperling | 2 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Alessandro Maggiori (Italian); Harry G. Sperling | 2 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | William à Court, 1st Baron Heytesbury, Heytesbury House, Wiltshire (probably by 1823–d. 1860; purchased in Madrid); his son, William Henry Ashe Holmes à Court, 2nd Baron Heytesbury, Heytesbury House (1860–d. 1891); his grandson, William Frederick Holmes-à Court, 3rd Baron Heytesbury, Heytesbury House (1891–d. 1903); his widow, Margaret Anna, Lady Heytesbury, Heytesbury House (1903–d. 1920; her estate, 1920–26; her estate sale, Hampton & Sons and Edens, Heytesbury, April 27, 1926, no. 1329, for £39.18); [Julius Böhler, Munich, and F. Steinmeyer, Lucerne, by 1927–50; sold to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1950–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Wertmuller, Munich, sale Oct. 13-14, 1938, lot 125 ( as Rosalba Carriera); Dr. Scharf and H. Bier; Dr. Victor Bloch, his sale, November 19, 1963, lot 118; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | UnidentifiedFrench (?) Collector (Lugt 474); Walter Hugelshofer (Swiss)According to Harry G. Sperling; Galerie Fischer, Lucerne; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Unidentified Collector; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Thomas Banks (British); Ambrose Poynter (British); Sir Edward John Poynter (British, born France); his sale, Sotheby's, London, April 24–25, 1918, part of lot 57 (to Mathews); Richard George Mathews (Canadian); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Théodore Chassériau (French)Lugt 443; sale, Paris, Atelier du feu M. Théodore Chassériau, March 16-17, 1857, no. 75(?); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Teodor de Wyzewa; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Sotheby's, London; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Sotheby's, London- sale March 27, 1969, p. 165, no 252(not reproduced) (bought by H. G. Sperling); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Sir Peter Lely (Pieter van der Faes) (Dutch, British)Lugt 2092; Peter Sylvester Lugt 2877; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Samuel van Huls (Dutch); probably his sale, The Hague, May 14, 1736, album A, no. 63; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Robert Fullarton Udny (British)(according to Esdaile's inscription on verso); William Esdaile (British); Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Professor J[acob]. Isaacs (British); Sotheby's, London- January 28, 1965, no. 147; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Private collection, France In Paris, according to Sandoz; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Princess Lubomiriski , Countess of Wisnicz and Jaroslaw (Poland), According to Sperling's inscription on mount; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Possibly Reinier Willem Petrus de Vries; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Possibly owned by Samuel van Huls (Dutch), his sale, Swart, The Hague, 14 May 1736Album XX, no. 2795; Adolph Gottlob von Quandt (German); sale Christie's, London, 28 June 1960, lot 77; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | possibly Cornelis Bloemaert (Dutch); possibly Arnold van Westerhout (Flemish); possibly Nicolas Vleughels (French); possibly Art market, Paris, ca. 1903-1905; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Peter Sylvester; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Paul Sandby (British); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Paul Leford (French)(see curatorial remarks); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Page Not Found | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | P. & D. Colnaghi & Co., June 1954; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Nikita D. Lobanov; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Nicholas Lanier (British); John Talman (British)Lugt 2462; Mrs. Hermace Elemant Elemant sale, Christie's, June 28, 1966, no. 145; her sale Christie's, London, June 28, 1966, lot 145; Alister Mathews (British); Harry G. Sperling; Vendor: Alister Mathews (British) | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Nicholas Lanier (British); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Mrs. Gutekunst- London; P. & D. Colnaghi & Co.; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Mr. and Mrs. George L. Mesker, Palm Beach (until his d. 1935/36); Mrs. George L. (Elizabeth D.) Mesker, Palm Beach (1935/36–1943; her estate sale, Parke-Bernet, New York, October 27–30, 1943, no. 501, for $775); [Arnold Seligman, Rey & Co., New York, 1943–44; sold for $8000 to Minneapolis]; Minneapolis Institute of Arts (1944–58; sold to Weitzner); [Julius Weitzner, New York, from 1958]; Mr. Endicott, New York (until 1960; sold to Newhouse and de Boer); [Newhouse, New York, and P. de Boer, Amsterdam, 1960]; [P. de Boer, Amsterdam, 1961; sold to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1961–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Modesto Ignazio Bonaventura Luigi Genevosio (Italian); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Michel David-Weill; P. & D. Colnaghi & Co.; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Michael Jaffé (British), Cambridge; Sotheby's, London- July 1, 1965, p. 58, no. 141, as Lanfranco.; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Mendelsohn-Bartholdi According to Sperling's inscription on mount. No mention of this collection in Lugt.; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Meijer Elte, The Hague; Harry G. Sperling; F. A. Drey, London-New York | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Maurice Marignane (French); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Maurice Marignane (French)- according to A. Ballarin; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Martin B. Asscher; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Marquis de Feronni; Etienne Desperet (French)(Lugt 721); Leo Franklyn (German); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Marqués de Casa Torres; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Marie Marignane-Patissou; Harry G. Sperling, 1906-1971 | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Margaret Mackail (British); Angela Thirkell (British); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Madame Galippe; Reinier Willem Petrus de Vries- Sale March 27, 29, 1923, p. 48, no. 516; Dr. Fritz Haussmann (German)- Berlin; Countess Finckenstein(see Clark and Bowron, 1895, p. 377; Yvonne French (British); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Ludwig Heinrich Bojanus (Russian); Acquired in 1829 by Hessisches Landesmuseum(see mark and number on verso); sold or exchanged between 1936 and 1945 with Galerie Fischer, Lucernesale , 11/30/1956, no.442, as Canaletto; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Lambert Sigisbert Adam (French); Harry G. Sperling; Vendor: Adolphe Stein | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Lady Harcourt; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | L. D. Séguin Séguin's coat of arms is on the binding of the album, in which this sheet was once bound.; Count N. A. Koucheleff Bezborodko Lugt 1629; Count Jan Pieter van Suchtelen (or Souktelen) (Russian)Lugt 2332; Eugene von Wassermann sale, Brussels, Galerie Georges Giroux, Oct. 24- Nov. 5, 1921, lot 954.; G. Tyser sale, Sotheby's, London, April 9, 1970, no. 131 [sold with MMA 1975.131.99], not repr. (sold as a portrait of Louis-Antoine de Marne); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | L. D. Séguin Président de la Chambre des Comtes de Paris. Séguin's coat of arms is on the binding of the album, in which this sheet was once bound.; Count N. A. Koucheleff Bezborodko Chancellor of Catherine the Great of Russia, Lugt 1629; Count Jan Pieter van Suchtelen (or Souktelen) (Russian)Lugt 2332; Eugene von Wassermann sale, Brussels, Galerie Georges Giroux, Oct. 24- Nov. 5, 1921, lot 954.; G. Tyser sale, London, Sotheby's, April 9, 1970, no. 131 [sold with MMA 1975.131.100], not repr. (sold as a portrait of Louis-Antoine de Marne); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Jules Porgès, Paris; [Guy Stein and D'Atri, Paris, until 1963]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1963–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Jules Porges, Paris; [Guy Stein and D'Atri, Paris, until 1963]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1963–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Joseph-Guillaume-Jean Camberlyn; Maison F. A. C. Prestel(Lugt 2730); Eugène Rodrigues(Lugt 897); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Jonathan Richardson Sr. (British); Harry G. Sperling- New York | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | John Thane (British); Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); William Esdaile (British)no.113 (as Cellini); Christie's, London, June 18, 1840, part of lot 113 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); A. E. Williamson; sale, Sotheby's, Londonsale June 21, 1950, part of lot 22 (as by Benvenuto Cellini)not repr. (as Cellini), withdrawn from sale; Christie's, LondonNov. 30, 1965, part of lot 13(as Cellini); sale, Christie's, London, November, 30, 1965, part of lot 13; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | John Thane (British); Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); William Esdaile (British); his sale, Christie's, London, June 18, 1840, part of lot 113 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); A. E. Williamson; Sotheby's, London, June 21, 1950, lot 20 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); sale, Christie's, London, November 30, 1965, part of lot 13; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | John Thane (British); Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); William Esdaile (British); his sale, Christie's, London, June 18, 1840, part of lot 113 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); A. E. Williamson; sale, Sotheby's, London, June 21, 1950, part of lot 19 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); Christie's, London, November 30, 1965, part of lot 13; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | John Thane (British); Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); William Esdaile (British); Christie's, London, June 18, 1840, part of lot 113 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); A. E. Williamson; sale, Sotheby's, London, June 21, 1950, part of lot 20 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); Christie's, London, , November, 30, 1965, part of lot 13; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | John Thane (British); Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); William Esdaile (British); Christie's, London, June 18, 1840, part of lot 113 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); A. E. Williamson; Ockham; Lord Tredegar, Baron Tredegar (British); Leo Franklyn (German); sale, Sotheby's, LondonJune 21, 1950, part of lot 19 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | John Thane (British); Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); William Esdaile (British); Christie's, London, June 18, 1840, part of lot 113 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); A. E. Williamson; Ockham; Lord Tredegar, Baron Tredegar (British); Leo Franklyn (German); sale, Sotheby's, London, June 21, 1950, part of lot 19 (as by Benvenuto Cellini); sale, Christie's, London, November, 30, 1965, part of lot 13; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | John Thane (British), his sale, London, sold by Mr. King, May 17-31, 1819; Private Collection, Scotland1939; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | John MacGowan(stamp Lugt 1496); His salein 1804 (see provenance notes for details); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | John B. Skippe (British); By descent to Mrs. A. D. Rayner-Wood Descendant of John Skippe; the Martin family including Edward Holland-Martin.; By descent to Edward Holland-Martin Descendant of John Skippe; the Martin family, including Mrs. A. D. Rayner-Wood.; Skippe Sale, Christie's, London11/20-21/1958, no. 263A, as Venetian SchoolNovember, 20-21, 1958, no. 263 A, as Venetian School, 16th century.; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Jean Masson Lugt 149a; though stamp is in purple rather than the usual black; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Jan van Rymsdyk (British)(ca. 1720–1790); presumably his sale, London, Greenwood's, 29 March 1790; John Thane (British)(1748–1818), London; Sir Thomas Lawrence (British)(1769–1830), London; acquired in 1833 by William Esdaile (British)(1758–1837), London; Mathias Komor (1909–1984), New York; Anton Schmid (Austrian)(b. 1904), New York; Harry G. Sperling (1906–1971) | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Jan Pietersz Zoomer; Valerius Röver; Johann Edler Goll van Franckenstein (Dutch); Johan Goll van Franckenstein Sr.; Pieter Hendrik Goll van Franckenstein; William Esdaile (British); his sale, Christie's, London, June 23, 1840, lot 1024 (as by Rembrandt); Robert Stayner Holford (British); his sale, Christie's, London, July 11–14, 1893, lot 665 (as by Rembrandt); Frank T. Sabin (British); Martin B. Asscher; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Jacob de Vos (Dutch); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Hon. Mrs. Ethel Mary Trollope, Crowcombe Court, near Taunton, Somerset (by 1907–d. 1934; as "The Earl of Northumberland" by Rubens, later as by Thomas de Keyser); her grandson, Major Thomas Fleming Trollope-Bellew, Crowcombe, Taunton (from 1934); [Martin Asscher, London, until 1967; sold to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1967–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Herbert Norman Bier (German); Harry G. Sperling, purchased by him in London in 1963. | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Herbert Norman Bier (German); Harry G. Sperling- purchased by him in London in 1963. | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Henry Scipio Reitlinger (British); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Heinz Kisters, Kreuzlingen, Switzerland (in 1965); private collection (until 1968; sold to Böhler); [Julius Böhler, Munich, 1968–1969; sold to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1969–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Harry G. Sperling( as Pietro Malombra, 1556-1618) | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Harry G. Sperling, New York (until d. 1971; his bequest to MMA) | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Harry G. Sperling, bequeathed to the museum in 1971 | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Harry G. Sperling, 1971 | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Harry G. Sperling- New York | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Harry G. Sperling Bought at sale, London, Sotheby's, June 25, 1970, no. 94 | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | H. Michel-Lévy Sale, Paris, Galerie Georges Petit, May 12-13, 1919, no. 47 (?). No note on the provenance of this drawing has been found among Sperling's papers. However, our drawing corresponds exactly to the dimensions and description of no. 697 in Ananoff 1966, p. 184, formerly in the collection of H. Michel-Lévy. Another version with similar dimensions (34 x 21 cm.), inscribed: Boucher, was recently seen on the Paris art market (cat. "Desrais," Paul Prouté et ses fils, Paris, 1967, p. 15, no. 29, repr.); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Gutekunst and Klipstein- May 28, 1953, no. 149; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Graf Karol Lanckoronski, Vienna (until d. 1933); Lanckoronski family or Gräfin Adelajda Lanckoronska, Vienna, Vorarlberg, and later Zurich (1933–67; seized by the Nazis in 1939, held at Alt Aussee [676] and at Munich collecting point [767], returned to Austria June 25, 1945; restituted; sale, Christie's, London, June 23, 1967, no. 76, as "Figures and Dogs on a Terrace with a Pool and Statues," by La Hyre, for £367.10.0 to Stein); [Adolphe Stein, London, 1967–68; sold for $4,000 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1968–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | George Thorn-Drury (British); William Bates (British); sale, Sotheby's, London, July 21, 1966, part of lot 101; Harry G. Sperling; Vendor: sale, Sotheby's, London July 21, 1966, part of lot no.101 George Thorn-Drury, K.C. was previous owner according to this sale catalogue | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | G. A. van der Wilde; Ernst Jürgen Otto(Lugt 873b); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Frank Hall Standish(until 1841)(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Louis Philippe, King of France (French)sale, Paris, December 6, 1852(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Sotheby's, London- sale January 27, 1966(p. 24, one of 5 items in lot 80, not reproduced); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Frank Hall Standish(until 1841)(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Louis Philippe, King of France (French)sale, Paris, December 6, 1852(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount; possibly the last undescribed drawing).; Sotheby's, London- sale, January 27, 1966(p. 24, one of 5 items in lot 80, not reproduced); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Frank Hall Standish(until 1841)(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Louis Philippe, King of France (French)Attributed to Francisco Herrera, the Younger ("El Mozo"), SpanisAttributed to Francisco Herrera, the Younger ("El Mozo"), Spanish, Seville 1627–1685 Madrid Male Saint with Staff, Half-Figure Spanish, 1622–85 Brush and gray wash, over black chalk underdrawing on off-white paper 6-1/16 x 4-1/2 in. (15.4 x 11.4 cm) This small brush drawing articulates the saint's ascetic figure in terms of broad areas of shadow and light, and with agitated contour strokes. It is part of a well-known series of individual representations of Christ and the apostles ("Apostolado") in half-length, all in the same scale and drawing technique. The drawings appear to have been conceived as finished works in and of themselves, and may have served a devotional purpose. The attribution of the "Apostolado" series has wavered between Herrera the Elder and his son Francisco de Herrera "El Mozo" (the Younger; 1627-1685), although the scale of critical opinion presently tips in favor of the father. Bequest of Harry G. Sperling, 1971 1975.131.220; Palais des Congrès, Versailles- sale March 1, 1970(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Frank Hall Standish(until 1841)(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Louis Philippe, King of France (French)Antonio del Castillo y Saavedra, Spanish, Cordoba 1616–1668 CordAntonio del Castillo y Saavedra, Spanish, Cordoba 1616–1668 Cordoba Half-lenth Figure of St. Andrew in an Oval. Spanish, 1616–68 Pen and light brown ink over traces of black chalk underdrawing on cream paper. Composition outlined with pen and brown ink in an oval shape 4-1/2 x 3-1/16 in. (11.4 x 7.8 cm) Annotated in pen and brown ink,"4" and "A. C." Bequest of Harry G. Sperling, 1971 1975.131.212; Sotheby's, London- sale Jan. 27, 1966, lot 80 (one of 5 items)(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Frank Hall Standish(until 1841)(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Louis Philippe, King of France (French)Antonio del Castillo y Saavedra, Spanish, Cordoba 1616–1668 CordAntonio del Castillo y Saavedra, Spanish, Cordoba 1616–1668 Cordoba Half-length Figure of St Paul in an Oval. Spanish, 1616–68 Pen and light brown ink over traces of black chalk underdrawing on cream paper. Composition outlined with pen and brown ink in an oval shape 4-1/2 x 3-1/16 in. (11.4 x 7.8 cm) Annotated in pen and brown ink, "2" and "A. C.". Bequest of Harry G. Sperling, 1971 1975.131.211; Sotheby's, London- sale January 27, 1966(one of 5 items in lot 80, not reproduced); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Frank Hall Standish(until 1841)(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Louis Philippe, King of France (French)Antonio del Castillo y Saavedra, Spanish, Cordoba 1616–1668 CordAntonio del Castillo y Saavedra, Spanish, Cordoba 1616–1668 Cordoba Figure of St. James the Great Seated in a Landscape Spanish, 1616–68 Pen and light brown ink over traces of black chalk underdrawing. Composition outlined with pen and brown ink. On tan paper 5-7/8 x 3-11/16 in. (14.9 x 9.4 cm) Annotated in pen and brown ink at upper right, "21", at lower right, "A.C." Bequest of Harry G. Sperling, 1971 1975.131.213; Sotheby's, London- sale January 27, 1966, p. 24, lot 80(one of 5 items); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Frank Hall Standish(until 1841)(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Louis Philippe, King of France (French)- Sale, Paris, December 6, 1852(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Palais des Congrès, Versailles- sale March 1, 1970(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Frank Hall Standish (according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Louis Philippe, King of France (French)sale, December 6, 1852(According to H. G. Sperling notation on old mount); Sotheby's, London- sale January 27, 1966(p. 24, part of lot 80, not reproduced); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Frank Hall Standish (according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Louis Philippe, King of France (French)- sale Paris, December 6, 1852(according to H.G.S. notation on old mount); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | F A Mayliss(according to inscription on verso); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Eustace Cecil, Lord Rockley (British); Evelyn Cecil, Lord Rockley (British)According to Hylton Thomas; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Eugène Delacroix (French)(his estate sale, Paris 1864); Thannhauser; Sotheby's(sale May 6, 1959, lot 30); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Ernst Jürgen Otto; Mrs. Abraham Solomon; her sale, Sotheby's, London, December 13, 1966, lot 107; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Erasmus Philipps (British); Sir Richard Philipps, 7th Baronet (British); Sir John Philipps, Baronet; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Emile Calando (French); Emile Calando, son (French); Marignane Collection; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Einar Perman, Stockholm (Swedish); P. & D. Colnaghi & Co.; Harry G. Sperling(acquired through Colnaghi, London 1964) | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Einar Perman, Stockholm (Swedish); P. & D. Colnaghi & Co.-1964; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Edwin S. Chapin, New York (American)- according to vendor - purchased in N.Y., 1975; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Edward Hodges, Esq. (British); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Edward Habich (German), his sale, Stuttgart, H.G. Gutekunst,April 27-29, 1899, no. 423; Cornelis Hofstede de Groot (Dutch), The Hague (until 1918; to de Bussy); A. de Bussy, his sale, Amsterdam, Paul BrandtApril 5 1954, no. 517, repr.; Kurt Meissner, Zürich (Swiss); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Ed. Schultze (Austrian)(L.909); Ferdinand Wecbrodt (Austrian)(L.2588); sale, Galerie Fischer, Lucerne, 25 June 1965, lot 692c; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Ed. Schultze (Austrian)(L. 906); Ferdinand Wecbrodt (Austrian)(L. 2588); sale, Galerie Fischer, Lucerne, 25 June 1965, lot 692c; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Ed. Schultze (Austrian)(L. 906); Ferdinand Wecbrodt (Austrian)(L. 2588); sale, Galerie Fischer, Lucerne, 25 June 1965, lot 692a; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Earl of Dalhousie (British, Scottish); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Duke of Aosta (Italian); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Dr. and Mrs. Victor Bloch, London; Sotheby's, LondonNov. 12, 1964, no. 94, not repr.; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Dr. Alfred Ritter von Wurzbach-Tannenberg; S. von Licht; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Denys Darcy; Cailac (French); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | David P. Sellar, London (until 1894; sale, Christie's, London, March 17, 1894, no. 111, for £105 to A. Smith); M. van Slochem, New York (in 1912); M. van Gelder, Uccle, near Brussels (in 1929); John Ringling, Sarasota (until 1930; sold to Böhler); [Julius Böhler, Munich, 1930; sold to Neuerburg]; Hermann Neuerburg, Hamburg (from 1930); Gottfried Neuerburg, Cologne (until 1961; sold to Böhler); [Julius Böhler, Munich, 1961–67; sold to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1967–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Count Moriz von Fries (Austrian); Harry G. Sperling; Vendor: Sotheby's, London sale July 1, 1965, p.49, no.119 | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | comte Robert de Pourtalès, Paris (by 1900–at least 1907); Jeanne de Pourtalès, baronne d'Adelsward, Paris (by 1909); comte James de Pourtalès, Paris (by 1959–66; sold to Mons); [Mons et Cie., Paris, from 1966]; [Allen Loebl, Paris, until 1967; sold to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1967–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Charles Callet (French); Delaurier (French), according to Chennevières, sold by Callet's son, Charles Callet, "poor painter who went mad."; Philippe de Chennevières (French)Lugt 2073; bought from Delaurier, March 1862; Chennevières sale, Paris, Hôtel Drouot, April 4 - 7, 1900, lot 58. Sold to baron Roger de Portalis for 27 francs.; Baron Roger Portalis (French), Lugt 2232, his sale, Paris, February 2 - 3, 1911, lot 16 (lot included thirteen drawings by Callet: "études et compositions, la plupart relatives à la mythologie"), sold to unknown collector for 62 francs.; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Charles Albert de Burlet; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | C. M. A. A. Lindeman; J. Zarnowski, 1950; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Baron Dominique Vivant Denon (French); Amédée-Paul-Emil Gasc; Charles Gasc (French); Alfred Aaron de Pass (South African); gave to the following; The Royal Cornwall Museum, Truro; Christie's, London- Nov. 30, 1965, no. 135; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | August Artaria (Austrian); F. Kleinberger Galleries; Harry G. Sperling, New York | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Armand Sigwalt(L. 175); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Antonio Morassi; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Anton Schmid (Austrian); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Alfredo Viggiano (Italian); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Alexandre Tardieu (French), according to inscription on the verso.; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Alan Loebl, 1950; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | Aimé-Charles-Horace His de la Salle (French); Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | [Rothman, London, until 1958; sold for $3,780 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1958–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | [Martin Asscher, London, until 1960; as by Nicolas Largilliere; sold for $5,200 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1960–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | [Galerie Marcus, Paris, after 1945–68; sold for $4,000 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1968–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | [Galerie Marcus, Paris, after 1945–1967; sold for $2,800 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1967–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | [Edward Speelman, London, until 1958; sold for $850 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1958–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | [Edward Speelman, London, 1967, purchased in Switzerland; sold for $12,000 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1967–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | [Duits, London, until 1961; sold for $10,000 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1961–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | [de Beer, London, until 1963; sold for $950 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1963–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | [Ambroselli, Paris, until 1968; as by Jacques-Louis David; sold for $3,500 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1968–71; as "Study for Sabine Women"; half share exchanged with Ambroselli]; [Kleinberger, New York, and Ambroselli, Paris, 1971–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of Kleinberger, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | ?Sir Joshua Reynolds, London (possibly acting as agent for Chambers); ?Sir William Chambers, London, Hampton Court, and Whitton Place, near Hounslow (until d. 1796); by descent to George Chambers; Chambers family; Miss E. M. Chambers (until 1957; sold to Leger); [Leger, London, 1957; sold for £800 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1957–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | ?Sebastián Martínez y Pérez, Madrid (before d. 1800); Delaval Loftus Astley, 18th Baron Hastings, Melton Constable, Norfolk (until d. 1872); his son, Bernard Edward Delaval Astley, 19th Baron Hastings, Melton Constable, (1872–d. 1875); his brother, George Manners Astley, 20th Baron Hastings, Melton Constable, (1875–d. 1904); his son, Albert Edward Delaval Astley, 21st Baron Hastings, Melton Constable, (1904–63; sale, Christie's, London, May 24, 1963, $2,352 to "Spence" [Abdy]); Robert Henry Edward Abdy, London (1963–65; sold to Kleinberger); [Kleinberger, New York, 1965–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | ?Marie Darbisse (until d.; posthumous inv., 1744; claimed by Hallé); ?her godson, the painter's son, Noël Hallé, Paris (1744–d. 1781); ?his widow, Françoise Geneviève Lorry Hallé (from 1781; given to her son, Jean Noël); ?her son, Jean Noël Hallé (by 1785); [Ambroselli, Paris, until 1969; as "L'Hérésie détruite (Révocation de l'Édit de Nantes)," by Charles Le Brun; share exchanged with Kleinberger]; [Ambroselli, Paris, and Kleinberger, New York, 1969–71; half share exchanged with Ambroselli]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1971–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | ?Chalandon family, Paris; [dealer, ?Paris, until 1949]; [Otto Wertheimer, Paris, 1949–58; as by Pontormo; sold for $4,762 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1958–75; as by Pontormo, later as by Pier Francesco Foschi; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | François Flameng (French); his sale, Georges Petit, May 25/26, 1919, no. 77 (as Rembrandt); F. Gentile da Giuseppe(1933); Mrs. Raphael Salem; Harry G. Sperling | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling | [Galerie Marcus, Paris, after 1945–68; sold for $4,000 to Kleinberger]; [Kleinberger, New York, 1968–75; bequeathed by Harry G. Sperling, last surviving partner of firm, to The Met] | 1 |
| Bequest of Harry G. Sperling Total | 265 | |
| FUND | Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 40 |
| FUND | Antiquariat Peter Kiefer, Pforzheim, 1-2 Feb 2013, part of lot 7153; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 16 |
| FUND | Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 13 |
| FUND | Vendor: Norman Brosterman | 11 |
| FUND | Marquis Charles-Philippe de Chennevières-Pointel (French); Vendor: Brady, W. M. and Co., Inc. | 11 |
| FUND | Vendor: Thomas le Claire Kunsthandel, Hamburg | 7 |
| FUND | Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 6 |
| FUND | Carl Heumann (German); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 6 |
| FUND | Vendor: P. & D. Colnaghi & Co. | 5 |
| FUND | Vendor: Joseph Fach | 4 |
| FUND | Descendents of Eduard Julius Friedrich Bendemann (German); Galerie Bassenge (German), December 1, 2006, part of lot 5639; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 4 |
| FUND | Carle (Charles André) Vanloo (French), his sale, Paris, September 12, 1765, part of lot 11 (seven drawings).; Jacques Augustin de Silvestre (French); Marius Paulme; Private Collection, Paris , (possibly Deuillet ? according to Sahut and Rosenberg), sale, Paris, Galerie Georges Petit, April 27, 1932, lot 39.; Private Collection, Paris , (possibly Cotnareanu ? according to Sahut and Rosenberg), sale, Paris, Palais Galliera, Dec. 14, 1960, lot 9.; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 4 |
| FUND | William Esdaile (British); François Fagel, Sr., The Hague (Dutch); Vendor: Peter Rowlands | 3 |
| FUND | Vendor: Monroe Warshaw | 3 |
| FUND | Vendor: Colnaghi, New York | 3 |
| FUND | Vendor: C. G. Boerner LLC, New York (American) | 3 |
| FUND | Vendor: Brady, W. M. and Co., Inc. | 3 |
| FUND | sale, Karl & Faber, 04 December 2008, lot 224; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 3 |
| FUND | Mia N. Weiner | 3 |
| FUND | Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 3 |
| FUND | Colnaghi, New York | 3 |
| FUND | Anonymous sale, Sotheby's, London, April 19, 1992, lot 28, bought by the following; Private Collection, United Kingdomsold by "a gentleman" at the following; Sale, Sotheby's, London, December 4, 2008, lot 117 (by a gentleman); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 3 |
| FUND | Vendor: Morton Morris & Co., London | 2 |
| FUND | Vendor: Jean Cailleux (French) | 2 |
| FUND | Vendor: Galerie de la Scala, Paris | 2 |
| FUND | Vendor: Galerie Amicorum, Paris (French) | 2 |
| FUND | Vendor: Emanuel von Baeyer | 2 |
| FUND | Sir Peter Lely (Pieter van der Faes) (Dutch, British); William Gibson (British); Jonathan Richardson Sr. (British); Sir William Marcus John Worsley (British) | 2 |
| FUND | sale, Karl & Faber, 28 November 2008, lot 161; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 2 |
| FUND | sale, Bruun Rasmussen, Copenhagen, November 18, 2008, part of lot 795/601; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 2 |
| FUND | Pietro Scarpa | 2 |
| FUND | no provenance (Credit Line: Harry G. Sperling Fund, 1991) | 2 |
| FUND | no provenance | 2 |
| FUND | Lucien Goldschmidt | 2 |
| FUND | Galerie Koller AG, 20 Sept 2013 (A166), lot 3435; Johann Carl Hedlinger; Carl von Hettlingen (Swiss); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 2 |
| FUND | Galerie de Bayser, Paris; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 2 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), June 1, 2018 (lot 6584); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 2 |
| FUND | Friedrich August II of Saxony; Galerie Bassenge (German), December 2, 2005, lot 5787; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 2 |
| FUND | Christie's, LondonApril 10, 1985, part of no. 75, recto repr.; John Morton Morris (British) | 2 |
| FUND | Wynne R.H. Jeudwine (British); Ralph Holland, London; His sale, Sotheby's, London, 5 July, 2013, lot. 421; Vendor: Martin Hirschboeck (German) | 1 |
| FUND | Workart, Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | William Young Ottley (British)- on an Ottley mount, see Lugt Supp. 2662; his sale, Thomas Philipe (British), London, June 6–23, 1814, lot 1409 as Jacopo Vignali; Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); Hans M. Calmann (British); Christie's, London, April 7, 1981, lot 49 | 1 |
| FUND | William Roscoe (British); Fountaine Walker; Vendor: Paul McCarron | 1 |
| FUND | William Esdaile (British); Vendor: John Morton Morris (British) | 1 |
| FUND | William Esdaile (British); sale, Christie's, London, April 5, 1977, lot 8, repr. | 1 |
| FUND | W. C. Atkinson, sold at the following; Sotheby's, London, March 29th, 1961, lot 61; Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd., bought at the preceding; Private Collection, Scotland, until 2000; Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd., in 2001; Vendor: Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd. | 1 |
| FUND | W. A. Freund; de Vries sale February 20-21, 1901 (possibly sale of W.A. Freund); Marquis de Grange de Surgères his sale, Brussels, June 14, 1921, lot 222 (as Maturino?); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Vladamir Argutinsky-Dologorukov; his sale, Reinier Willem Petrus de Vries Jr., March 27, 1925, lot 180(as by the artist Lastman); sale, Sotheby's, London, July 4, 2007, lot 66; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Yvonne French (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Wildenstein & Co., Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Viebahn Fine Arts | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Unidentified Collector (Purchased in London in 1975) | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Trinity Fine Art, London | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Swann Galleries, Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Stiebel Ltd. | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Sotheby's, New York , sale 13 January 1993, no. 121 | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Selz | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Pamela Gordon | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Nonesuch Gallery | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Neal Fiertag | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Maurizio Nobile DP | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Lutz Riester (German) | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Lorna Lowe purchased from London in 1975 | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Lawrence Steigrad Fine Arts | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich Vendor: sale, Christie's, London , 5 July 2011, lot 81 | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Joseph Fach (Katalog 84, 2002, pp. 42-43, ill.) | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: John Morton Morris (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: J. Lishawa & Co. Ltd., London | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Hill-Stone, Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris Purchased in 1979. | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris (1977, no. 14) | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Galerie Arnoldi-Livie (German) | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Eric Gillis | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Dr. Robert Keil (Austrian) | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Dickinson Roundell Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Christophe Janet | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Boquet & Marty de Cambiaire | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Artis Fine Art Ltd. (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Alfred Strölin (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: Adolphe Stein | 1 |
| FUND | UnidentifiedFrench (?) Collector (Lugt 474); Dr. Carl Robert Rudolf; his sale, Sotheby's, London, May 19, 1977, lot 99 as ascribed to Giacomo Cavedone, repr.; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Unidentified Collector; Vendor: Emanuel von Baeyer | 1 |
| FUND | Unidentified Collector; Sotheby's, London, Sale, June 30, 1986, lot 127; Private Collection, England; Thomas Williams Fine Art Ltd., London; Vendor: Thomas Williams Fine Art Ltd., London | 1 |
| FUND | Thomas Nicolay Fearnley (Norwegian), the artist's son; Elisabeth Fearnley, the artist's great-granddaughter; inherited in 1994 by a descendant of Elisabeth Fearnley (British); sold by the preceding at the sale, Sotheby's, London, June 13, 2006, lot 136; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Thomas le Claire Kunsthandel, Hamburg, ca. 1986; Private Collection, Germany; sale, Kunsthaus Lempertz, May 12, 2012, lot 1501; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Thomas le Claire Kunsthandel, Hamburg | 1 |
| FUND | Thomas Coke, 1st Earl of Leicester (British); Christie's, London, Holkham sale, July 2, 1991, lot 10; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandeland Galerie de Bayser (New York, Paris, London 1994, lot. 10); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd.; Sale Christie's, London, December 10, 2008, lot 34; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | The Trustees of the Knole Settled Estates- according to Christie's; Christie's, London- April 1, 1987, no. 108, repr.; Aldega and Gordon- purchased in New York 1988 | 1 |
| FUND | the artist's wife, Ida Hammershøi, née Ilsted (Danish); given by her to Frederik H. Jacobsen (Danish); sale, Bruun Rasmussen Kunstauktioner, Copenhagen, March 1, 2016, lot 862/2; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Swann Galleries, Inc., January 31, 2002lot 21; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Swann Galleries, Inc., January 23, 2003, lot 323 (as Johann Heintz); Galerie Bassenge (German), May 25, 2006, lot 5567; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Sotheby's, New York, January 25, 2006, lot 120; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Sotheby's, Monaco, Monte Carlo, December 8, 1984; John Morton Morris (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Sotheby's, Monaco December 8, 1984, lot 56.; Vendor: Jean Cailleux (French)Purchased in Paris in 1985 | 1 |
| FUND | Sotheby's, London- sale Dec. 13, 1973, no. 17 (purchased in 1974) | 1 |
| FUND | Sotheby's, London- July 4, 1988, no. 21; John Morton Morris (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Sotheby's, London- December 10, 1979, no. 294, repr.; Yvonne Tan Bunzl | 1 |
| FUND | Sotheby's, London Nov. 18, 1982, no. 17, not repr., as French School, early 18th century; Vendor: P. & D. Colnaghi & Co. | 1 |
| FUND | Sir William Marcus John Worsley (British); Private Collection, Denmark(according to Sotheby's); Sale, Sotheby's, London, March 25, 1982, lot 7 | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Thomas Robinson, acquired from the artist or from Anton Pichler; Robert Wilson Reford (Canadian); his sale, Christie's, London, February 25, 1969, lot 174 (as bu Johann Pichler); Ralph Holland, London; his sale, Sotheby's, London, July 5, 2013, lot 340; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); Samuel Woodburn (British); his sale Christie's, London, June 4, 1860, part of lot 1074(bought by Phillipps); Sir Thomas Phillipps, 1st Baronet (British); Thomas Fitzroy Fenwick (British)(by descent from Sir Thomas Phillipps); Abraham Simon Wolf Rosenbach (American)(bought from T. Fitzroy Fenwick in 1930); Philip H.and A.S.W. Rosenbach Foundation, until 1978; British Rail Pension Fund (British); Sotheby's, New York, January 11, 1990, lot 39 (repr.); Brady, W. M. and Co., Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Thomas Lawrence (British); Robert M. Light; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Robert Ludwig Mond (British); sale, Christie's, Paris, March 27, 2003, lot 48; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Richard Westmacott (British); Maria Westmacott Poole (British), daugher of the preceding; Christie's, London, November 20, 2003, lot 7 (album); Vendor: Richard L. Feigen & Co. | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Peter Lely (Pieter van der Faes) (Dutch, British); William Gibson (British), London; Jonathan Richardson Sr. (British); Sir William Marcus John Worsley (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Peter Lely (Pieter van der Faes) (Dutch, British); possibly acquired by Thomas Herbert, 8th Earl of Pembroke (British); Henry Herbert, 10th Earl of Pembroke (British), by 1772; by descent to Reginald Herbert, 15th Earl of Pembroke (British); Pembroke sale, Sotheby's, London, 07/5-6,9-10/1917, no.420, as V. di Biagio; Karl & Faber, 11/25-27/1976, no. 362a | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Joshua Reynolds (British); Vendor: Sir Anthony Blunt (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Charles Hood (British); Sale, Christie's, London, March 28, 1870, lot 318; Mr. Ryder (British), purchased at the preceding; Sale, Bigwoods Fine Art Auctioneers (British), June 30, 2006; Vendor: Sim Fine Art (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Charles D'Oyly (British); The Coln Gallery; Michael Spratt; Sale, Sotheby's, London, Nov. 22, 2007, lot 168; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Anthony Westcombe, 2nd Baronet (British)(no evidence of his mark on drawing or mount); Thomas Bateman(according to inscription on old mount); Adolphe Stein | 1 |
| FUND | Sir Anthony Blunt (British); Vendor: P. & D. Colnaghi & Co. | 1 |
| FUND | SIGALAS Auktionen, 18 Sept 2008; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Santo Varni; P. & D. Colnaghi & Co. | 1 |
| FUND | Sandby Family Album (British)(work was contained in); Private Collection, United Kingdom(until 2008); Vendor: W.S Fine Art Ltd. / Andrew Wyld (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Sandby Family Album (British)(work previously contained in ); Private Collection, United Kingdom(until 2008); Vendor: W.S Fine Art Ltd. / Andrew Wyld (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Sandby Family Album (British)(work previoulsy contained in); Private Collection, United Kingdom(until 2008); Vendor: W.S Fine Art Ltd. / Andrew Wyld (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Sammlung Lumnitzer-Brünn; Sale Dorotheum (Austrian), September 29, 2004, lot 181; Sale Christie's, London, December 10, 2008, lot 1; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Salle des Ventes - Fontainebleau , June 17, 1984, no cat. nos., no page nos., repr. (according to Christine Gouzi) | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Weinmüller18 June 1952, no. 820 repr.; sale, Karl & Faber, 07 Dec 2006, no. 513 repr.; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Villa Grisebach Auktionen, Berlin, November 23, 2011, lot 122R; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Villa Grisebach Auktionen, Berlin, May 30, 2012, lot 188; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Villa Grisebach Auktionen, Berlin, June 2-4, 2016, lot 300; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Stack's, New York, May 8, 1952, no. 71, as "La ville Adrien, près Tivoli et Roma," by School of Corot; private collection, Stony Point, N.Y. (until 1977; sold to Rochat); [Guillaume F. Rochat, New York, 1977; sold to Lishawa]; [J. Lishawa & Co., London, 1977; sold on December 20 to The Met] | 1 |
| FUND | Sale, Sotheby's, New YorkJanuary 23, 2001, lot 147; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Sotheby's, New YorkJan1989, lot 27; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Sotheby's, New York, 27 Jan 2016, lot 3 (aftersale); A. Alfred Taubman; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Sale, Sotheby's, London, May 21, 1963, lot 91 (with pendant of Justice); Dr. Carl Robert Rudolf; his sale, Sotheby's, Amsterdam, June 6, 1977, lot 6; sale, Sotheby's, New York, January 13, 1989; Private Collection; sale, Sotheby's, London, July 4, 2007, lot 8; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Sotheby's, London, July 4, 2007, lot 193; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Sale, Sotheby's, London, December 7, 1976, part of no. 31Sale, London, December 7, 1976, part of no. 31, as Cherubino Alberti.; Sotheby's, New York Purchased in New York. | 1 |
| FUND | Sale, Sotheby's, London, December 7, 1976, part of no. 31; Yvonne Tan Bunzl, London (through Anstalt) | 1 |
| FUND | Sale, Sotheby's, London, April 3, 1995, lot 258(as by an anonymous Flemish artist of the 17th century); Private Collection, Nordrhein-Westfalen; sale, Karl & Faber, December 3, 2010, lot 155; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Kunstauktionshaus Schloss Ahlden, December 3, 2011, lot 1252; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Ketterer Kunst, Hamburg, October 27, 2007, lot 1142; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Karl & Faber, November 29, 2005, lot 249; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Karl & Faber, Munich, November 29, 2005, lot; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Karl & Faber, Munich, November 29, 2005, lot 381; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Karl & Faber, May 30, 2006, lot 245; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Karl & Faber, December 7, 2006, part of no. 549; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Karl & Faber, December 3, 2010, lot 136; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Karl & Faber, 04 December 2008, lot 394; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Karl & Faber, 04 December 2008, lot 159; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, June 30, 1995, lot 18; Jean-Jacques Senon (French); his sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, April 2, 2012, lot 47; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, December 5, 2005, part of lot 6(as attributed to Isaac de Moucheron); Vendor: Galerie Amicorum, Paris (French) | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Cobb's (American), June 1997; Seaves & McLellan Antiques, Dublin, June 1997; Trifles, Bath (ME), June 1997; Vendor: Trifles | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Christie's, South Kensington, December 2, 2008, lot 385(as by an anonymous 17th-century Flemish artist); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Sale, Christie's, South Kensington, 02 Dec 2008, lot 380; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Christie's, London03 July 2007, lot 72; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Bruun Rasmussen, Copenhagen(Bredgade), April 23, 2008, lot 786/371; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Bruun Rasmussen, Copenhagen, November 19, 2008, lot 205; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Bruun Rasmussen Kunstauktioner, Copenhagen, December 30, 2013, lot 1401/53; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Bruun Rasmussen Kunstauktioner, Copenhagen (online), February 25, 2013, lot 1309/102; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Bruun Rasmussen Bredgade, Copenhagen, May 30, 2011, lot 59 (bought in); sale, Bruun Rasmussen Bredgade, Copenhagen, February 28, 2012, lot 827/73; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Bruun Rasmussen Bredgade, Copenhagen, February 29, 2012, lot 827/163; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Bruun Rasmussen Bredgade, Copenhagen, February 29, 2012, lot 827/160; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale, Antiquariat Peter Kiefer, Pforzheim, June 15-16, 2012, lot 4848; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | sale Sotheby's, Amsterdam,November 16, 2005, no. 154; Vendor: Galerie Nathalie Motte Masselink (French) | 1 |
| FUND | sale Sotheby's, Amsterdam, November 16, 2005, no. 180; Vendor: Galerie Nathalie Motte Masselink (French) | 1 |
| FUND | sale Sotheby's, Amsterdam, November 16, 2005, no. 164; Vendor: Galerie Nathalie Motte Masselink (French) | 1 |
| FUND | S. Sarphati; Frederik Muller & Cie (Dutch), sale, 19 November 1866, lot 1579; Johannes Hermanus Henricus Leonhardt (Dutch); George J.G. Leonhardt (Dutch)(his stamp, not in Lugt); G.E.A.M. Leonhardt-Pilz von Wernhof (Dutch); Christie's, Amsterdam, sale 20 November 1989, lot 238; E. H. Ariëns Kappers; Christie's, London, sale 3 July, 2018, lot 65; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Rudolph Ferdinand Hintze (German); Karl & Faber, November 29, 2005, lot 468; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Rudolph Ferdinand Hintze (German); Karl & Faber, November 29, 2005, lot 426; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Rodney Searight (British); Bill Thomson, sold at the following; Sotheby's, London, July 6, 2016 (324); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel Gift | 1 |
| FUND | Richard Holtkott, Bedburg (German), acquired December 23, 1934; Wolfgang Ratjen, Munich and Vaduz (German), inv. no. 298; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Rev. William Kingsley (British), by 1884, then bequeathed to the following; Sylvia Kingsley Hunt (Mrs. Fogg-Elliott) (British), god-daughter of the preceding, then by descent; Vendor: The Maas Gallery Ltd. (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Randon de Boisset sale, Paris, February 27 - March 25, 1777, part of lot 376; Vassal de Saint-Hubert sale, Paris, March 29 - April 12, 1779, part of lot 164; sale, Paris, April 24 - May 5, 1783, part of lot 159.; Georges Bourgarel Paris, Hôtel Drouot, June 15-16, 1922, part of lot 98; Sale, Paris , Nouveau Drouot, June 2, 1981, lot 38 | 1 |
| FUND | Randon de Boisset his sale, Paris, February 27 - March 25, 1777, part of no. 376; Vassal de Saint-Hubert his sale, Paris, March 29 - April 13, 1779, part of lot 164; sale, Paris, April 24 - May 5, 1783, part of lot 159; Georges Bourgarel his sale, Paris, Hôtel Drouot, June 15 - 16, 1922, part of lot 98; Nouveau Drouot, Paris June 2, 1981, no. 38, mistakenly attributed to Charles-Joseph Flipart; Vendor: Alfred Strölin (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Pupil of Adam Gutmann; Ernst Heinrich Ehlers (German); his sale, C. G. Boerner, Dusseldorf (German), May 25, 1938, lot 18(as by the artist Hans Guttman); Rosgartenmuseum Konstanz(acc. to annotated Boerner's catalogue); sale, Christie's, London, July 4, 2006, lot 50; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Professor Susini; Hôtel Drouot, Parisno.1, 06/04/1982, as Entourage de Pierre Cortone; P. & D. Colnaghi & Co. | 1 |
| FUND | Probably Sir William Forbes of Pitsligo, 7th Baronet (British, Scottish), thence by descent; Family at Fettercairn House, Kincardineshire, Scotland, to 2017; Vendor: Lowell Libson Ltd. (British) | 1 |
| FUND | probably Petrus Franciscus van Schorel, and his sale,Antwerp, June 7, 1774 and following days, drawings, lot 145 (sold to Van Schorel); sale, Sotheby's, London, June 22-23, 1954, part of lot 795; Christie's, London, February 18, 1955, lot 7; acquired at the sale by Leonard Koetser; given to him after the sale to Ludwig Burchard (German); given by him in 1957 to Frans Baudouin (Belgian); his widow, Paula Baudouin-Smolders (Belgian); Vendor: Lowet de Wotrenge Fine Art, Antwerp | 1 |
| FUND | Probably owned by Jan Pietersz. Zomer (Dutch)(1641-1724), Amsterdam; Karl Eduard Liphart; Reinhold von Liphart; his sale C. G. Boerner, Leipzig (German), sale 64, June 27,1899, lot 93 (as by P. Bruegel, 1600); Consul Bernhard Limburger, thence by descent; Vendor: Artemis Fine Arts SA Luxembourg (Swiss) | 1 |
| FUND | probably Count Christian Johan Frederik Ahlefeldt Laurvig (Danish); his descendants; sale, Winkel & Magnussen (Danish), November 2-7, 1939, lot 725; sale, Bruun Rasmussen Bredgade, Copenhagen, February 29, 2012, lot 827/166; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Probably Christina, Queen of Sweden (Swedish); Decio Cardinal Azzolini; Marchese Pompeo Azzolini; Prince Livio Odescalchi | 1 |
| FUND | Private collector (descendant of Benjamin West); Sotheby's, London, April 10, 1997, lot 26; Vendor: Christie's, London , July 5, 2016, lot 71 | 1 |
| FUND | Private collector (descendant of Benjamin West), sold at the following; Sotheby's, London, April 10, 1997, lot 26; Vendor: Christie's, London , July 5, 2016, lot 71 | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection; Vendor: Emanuel von Baeyer | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Zurich; Pestalozzi Collection, Zurich; Vendor: Joseph Fach | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Vienna; sale, Dorotheum (Austrian), April 20, 2010, lot 178; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Vienna , sale, Versailles, M. Blache (expert), March 13, 1966, lot 171.; Vendor: Cailleux (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Vienna , sale, Versailles, M. Blache (expert), March 13, 1966, lot 152.; Vendor: Cailleux (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, United Kingdom; on loan to Abbot Hall Art Gallery, from early 1980s until the late 1990s; W.S Fine Art Ltd. / Andrew Wyld (British), in 2002; Vendor: Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd. | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Ulmca. 1975; Galerie Bassenge (German), November 25, 2011, lot 6464; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Switzerland; Christie's, London, 3 July 2007, lot 12 (as Stefano da Verona); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, St. Louis , (according to Sotheby's); Sotheby Parke Bernet , January 20, 1982, lot 33, repr.; Vendor: Lucien Goldschmidt | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, South Germany; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; sale, Karl & Faber, May 30, 2006, lot 294; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Scotland; Richard Day | 1 |
| FUND | Private collection, Pennsylvania; Alfred Beurdeley II (French); Vendor: Freeman's Lot 554, Sale 1613, 10/16/18 | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Paris?; Sotheby's, Amsterdam, November 11, 1997, lot 49; Unicorno Collection (Saam Nijstad and Lily Nijstad -Einhorn, Amsterdam); Sotheby's, Amsterdam, May 19, 2004, lot 4; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Paris; Galerie de Bayser, Paris; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, New York; Thomas Williams Fine Art Ltd., London; Vendor: Thomas Williams Fine Art Ltd., London | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Munich, Brittany; Galerie de Bayser, Paris; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Private collection, Göteborg; sale, Uppsala Auktionskammare, Uppsala (Swedish), June 2, 2009, lot 58; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, Germany; Sotheby's, New York, January 25, 2006, lot 30; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Private collection, France(Lyon); Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Private collection, France; Vendor: Michael N. Altman (American) | 1 |
| FUND | Private collection, France; Vendor: Julius Böhler | 1 |
| FUND | Private collection, France; John Morton Morris (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Private Collection, England; sale, Christie's, London, July 6, 2004, lot 167; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Private collection, Berlin; Vendor: Julius Böhler , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Princes of Oettingen-Wallerstein, Harburg Castle, Germany (by at least early 19th century–2017) ; [ Rudigier Alte Kunst, Munich (acquired 2017)] ; [ Sam Fogg Ltd., London (sold 2022)] | 1 |
| FUND | Possibly, Everhard Jabach (German); Christie's, Paris, 26 March 2014, lot 57; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Possibly Zaccaria Sagredo (Italian)(see inscription); Comtesse de Noyant(according to Sotheby Parke Bernet catalogue); Sotheby Parke Bernet, May 21, 1975, lot 9, repr.; Vendor: Sotheby's, Los Angeles | 1 |
| FUND | Possibly previously owned by Emperor Rudolf II; Adalbert Freiherr von Lanna (Bohemian); his sale H. G. Gutekunst, Stuttgart (German), May 6-11, 1910, lot 596; Frau Toni Straus-Negbaur; her sale, Bruno Cassirer (German), November 25-26, 1930, lot 111; Private Collection, Germany; With Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | possibly in sale, L'Illustration (French), Amsterdam, December 9, 1776, Kbk. E, no.320; possibly in sale, L'Illustration (French), Metayer, Amsterdam, December 16, 1799, Kbk. I,no.4; sale, I. Schmidt and Hagedorn, Amsterdam, April 24, 1820, KbK. F, no.21; possibly in sale, I. van Idsinga, Amsterdam, November 2 1840, Kbk. H, no. 4; P. Langerhuizen sale, Muller, April 29, 1919, no. 544 [fl.100]; Henry Oppenheimer (British); his sale, Christie's, London, July 10, 13–14, 1936, lot 270A (£25 to Goldschmidt); Possibly Ernst Goldschmidt; Sale, Ader Tajan, Paris, October 28, 1994, lot 32, ill; William Pitcairn Knowles (British, Scottish); Johan Goll van Franckenstein Sr.; Pieter Langerhuizen; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | possibly Henrycollection sale, Paris November 26-28, 1816 (lot 159); possibly M. Pillotcollection sale, Paris, February 10-12, 1818 (lot 68); Baron and Baronness Gourgaud; Tajan, Paris, April 5, 2001, lot 14; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Possibly collection Sauvé (French)(according to Bazin), 1867; Sotheby's, New York, May 5, 1999, lot 7; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Pietro Scarpa, Sagredo Collection | 1 |
| FUND | Pierre Jean Mariette (French)Mariette sale, Paris, November 15, 1775 - January 30, 1776, lot 1117, sold to Lempereur for 160 livres; Jean Denis Lempereur (French)Lempereur sale, Paris, December 27 - 31, 1796, lot 117.; Paul Gavarni [Chevalier] (French)After May 17, 1867, given to the Goncourts by Pierre Gavarni, the son of the engraver. "Acheté 2 sous par Gavarni dans sa jeunesse, étalé ou? sur le boulevard du Temple, dans la boue!" (Launay, "Les Frères Goncourt," 231); Edmond de Goncourt (French)Goncourt sale on February 15, 1897, lot 18, 90 Francs.; G. Cotteret; Paul Suzor; Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Pierre Jean Mariette (French)Lugt 2097; Mariette sale, Paris, 1775-1776, part of no. 1186, "de l'École Françoise . . . CASANOVA. (Françoise), [no.] 1186 Deux Escarmouches de plusiers cavaliers, le sabre & le pistolet en mains, d'un grand effet, sur papier brun, à l'encre de la Chine, rehaussée de blanc."; Vendor: Alfred Strölin (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Pierre Jean Mariette (French)Lugt 2097; Mariette sale, Paris, 1775-1776, part of no. 1186, "de l'École Françoise . . . CASANOVA. (François), [no.] 1186 Deux Escarmouches de plusiers cavaliers, le sabre & le pistolet en mains, d'un grand effet, sur papier brun, à l'encre de la Chine, rehaussée de blanc."; Vendor: Alfred Strölin (French)Lausanne | 1 |
| FUND | Pierre Jean Mariette (French)Lugt 1852; Mariette sale, 1775-1776, part of lot 1268, "Saint Antoine chassant le diable"; Pierre Charbonnier (French); Defer-Dumesnil (French); Vendor: Brady, W. M. and Co., Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | Pierre Jean Mariette (French); sale, Paris, Nov. 15, 1775 - Jan. 30, 1776, expert F. Basan, part of no. 1127: "Les contre-épreuves, à la sanguine, des cinq sens de nature, représentés par des femmes debout sur un globe, avec des attributs analogues; elles sont connues par les Estampes gravées d'après par le C. de Caylus; les Dessins sont en Suede."; Philippe de Chennevières (French); Vendor: Jacques Petithory | 1 |
| FUND | Pierre Jean Mariette (French); Mariette Paris sale, 1775-76, no. 403 (as "Ure belle Tête de Vieillard"); Jean-Baptiste-Florentin-Gabriel de Meryan, marquis de Lagoy (French); Mathieu-Guillaume-Thérèse de Villenave (French); de Villenave sale, Paris, Alliance des arts (French), December 1–3, 5–8, 1842, lot 77; Frederik Muller & Cie (Dutch), November 20, 1882; Lanna Sale, Stuttgart; Sale, H. G. Gutekunst, Stuttgart (German), May 6–11, 1910, no. 135; acquired from a Parisian paris collector by Alfred Strölin (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Pierre Jean Mariette (French), Mariette sale, Paris, 1775–76, part of lot 1352 as "Deux Bacchanales, dans la composition desquelles il entre plus de quinze figures, faites à la plume et à l'encre de la Chine."; Juan Jorge Peoli (American); his sale, American Art Galleries, New York, May 8–12, 1894, lot 550 or 552; Christie's, London, April 12, 1983, lot 143, repr.; Vendor: Yvonne Tan Bunzl | 1 |
| FUND | Pierre François Basan (French); Wildenstein & Co., Inc. 1962; Vendor: Paul Drey Gallery, New York | 1 |
| FUND | Philippe de Chennevières (French), Lugt 2073. His sale, Paris, Hôtel Drouot, April 4 - 7, 1900, possibly part of lot 39: "Costume de Chinois. Portraits-charges. Costumes religieux. Sept dessins. A la plume et à sanguine." Sold to Grosjean for 15 francs (according to Louis-Antoine Prat, Chennevières exh. cat., 2007).; Grosjean; Pierre Guéraud , his sale, Enghien-les-Bains, Hôtel des ventes, Nov. 20, 1977, lot 18.; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Paul Wallraf (British)according to Georges Bernier, L'Oeil, Galerie d'art exhibition catalogue.; Georges Bernier; Vendor: Coe Kerr Gallery, New York | 1 |
| FUND | Paul Prouté, Paris (French); Vendor: Tobey C. Moss Gallery | 1 |
| FUND | Paul Meurice (French); bequeathed to his daughter;; Marthe Meurice (French); and by descent;; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Paul Fréart de Chantelou; Roland Fréart Sieur de Chambray (French); Private Collection, Lausanne; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Paul Arndt (German); Rudolph Ferdinand Hintze (German); Karl & Faber, November 29, 2005, lot 213; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | P. Sylvester (British); Jonathan Richardson Jr. (British); Dr. Edward Peart; Sotheby's, London, 2 July 1997, lot 142 (as Pynas); Egbert Haverkamp-Begemann (Dutch); Sotheby's, New York, 31 January 2018, lot; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | P. & D. Colnaghi & Co.(1951); Sotheby's, LondonMarch 6, 1973, no. 330, repr.; David Peel, London; Richard Day | 1 |
| FUND | P. & D. Colnaghi & Co., New York, May 1989, lot 8 (as Andrea Casolani); Christie's, London, 5 July 2011, lot 9 (as Poppi); Vendor: Acquired from Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel (Munich) in 2012 | 1 |
| FUND | Osenat, Fontainebleau, May 30, 2021 (lot 19); Christie's, Paris, March 26, 2003 (lot 88); Vendor: Galerie Terrades | 1 |
| FUND | Oger Blanchet, Paris, 26 March 2012, lot 13; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | no provenance (Credit Line: Harry G. Sperling Fund, 1994) | 1 |
| FUND | no provenance (Credit Line: Harry G. Sperling Fund, 1989) | 1 |
| FUND | no provenance (Credit Line: Harry G. Sperling and Rogers Funds, 1975) | 1 |
| FUND | Nicos Dikheos; sale, Christie's, Paris, December 16, 2005, lot 13; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Nicos Dhikéos; Vendor: Catherine Dubs (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Nicolò Simonelli; Sotheby's, London- sale April 9, 1981, no. 89, repr. p. 45; Moss | 1 |
| FUND | Nicolas de Magny; Dumon (according to Auquier); Private Collection, Munich, Gémenos (Bouches-du-Rhône); Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Nicholas Lanier (British); possibly acquired by Thomas Herbert, 8th Earl of Pembroke (British); Henry Herbert, 10th Earl of Pembroke (British), by 1772 (was in Pembroke volume XU.3. dated 25 Nov. 1772); by descent to Reginald Herbert, 15th Earl of Pembroke (British); Pembroke Sale, Sotheby's, London, July 5–6, 1917, no.447 (as School of Raphael) | 1 |
| FUND | Mrs. John Inglett Fortescue (British), commissioned work from the artist in 1785; Mrs. J. Leahy (British), sold work at Sotheby’s, London, April 20, 1972, lot 31; Sale, Sotheby's, London, March 12, 1987, lot 88 (by anonymous owner); Sale, Sotheby's, London, July 14, 2010, lot 64 (by anonymous owner); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Mr. Gorton (British)-- purchased from widow by G. Agnew, 1975; Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd., London--1976 | 1 |
| FUND | Mr. Gorton (British)-- of Norwich in the late 1920's; Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd. | 1 |
| FUND | Mr. and Mrs. E. Powis Jones; Vendor: C. G. Boerner LLC, New York (American) | 1 |
| FUND | Morton Morris & Co., London | 1 |
| FUND | Monroe Warshaw; Vendor: Monroe Warshaw | 1 |
| FUND | Miss Miriam Hartley (British); Sale, Sotheby's, London, March 16, 1978, lot 55 (by the preceding); Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd.; Private Collection, United States; Sale, Sotheby's, London, December 4, 2008, lot 124; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Millon & Associés, 29 June 2012, lot 28; Aguttes, June 09th 2009, lot 102; Piasa (French)(auction house), April 10th, 2008, lot 009; Christie's, Paris, March 22nd 2007, lot 50; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Melanie Metternich, née Zichy-Ferraris (Austrian); Private collection, France; its sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 4 May 2012, lot 2; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Melanie Metternich, née Zichy-Ferraris (Austrian); Private collection, France; its sale, Beaussant & Lefèvre (French), May 4, 2012, lot 66; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Melanie Metternich, née Zichy-Ferraris (Austrian); Private collection, France; its sale, Beaussant & Lefèvre (French), May 4, 2012, lot 57; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Melanie Metternich, née Zichy-Ferraris (Austrian); Private collection, France; its sale, Beaussant & Lefèvre (French), May 4, 2012, lot 56; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Melanie Metternich, née Zichy-Ferraris (Austrian); Private collection, France; its sale, Beaussant & Lefèvre (French), 4 May 2012, lot 67; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Melanie Metternich, née Zichy-Ferraris (Austrian); Private collection, France; it's sale, Beaussant & Lefèvre (French), 4 May 2012, lot 90; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Melanie Metternich, née Zichy-Ferraris (Austrian); Private collection, France; Beaussant & Lefèvre (French), 4 May 2012, lot 147; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Max Strauss (Austrian); his sale, Galerie H.O. Miethke, Vienna, May 2-4, 1906, probably lot 151; sale, Van Ham Kunstauktionen, April 21, 2007, lot 2178; sale, Villa Grisebach Auktionen, Berlin, November 23, 2011, lot 167; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Mathieu-Guillaume-Thérèse de Villenave (French)(Lugt 2598), Alliance des Arts, Villenave sale, Paris, Dec. 1 and following days, 1842, lot 617; Galerie de Bayser, Paris; Vendor: Adrian Ward-Jackson Purchased in London in 1978 | 1 |
| FUND | Mathias Komor; Christian Humann Foundation; Vendor: Galerie Arnoldi-Livie (German) | 1 |
| FUND | Massol, October 18, 2002 (lot 88); Sotheby's, New York, January 21, 2003 (lot 109); Christie's, Paris, March 18, 2004 (lot 140); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Marquis Charles-Philippe de Chennevières-Pointel (French)Sale, Paris, Hôtel Drouot, April 4 - 7,1900, part of lot 403: "Jeune ouvrière assise et travaillant. Groupe de soudards couchés auprés d'une tente. Sujet tiré de l'Enéïde de Virgile. Trois dessins. A la sanguine et à la plume lavé de sépia."; Roblin , purchased for 125 francs (according to Louis-Antoine Prat, Chennevières exh. cat. 2007).; Michel Gaud (French), in 1978.; Vendor: Didier Aaron, Inc. (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Major-General Arthur K. Hay DSO OBE (British), by descent to the following; Joseph B. Hay (British), his executor's sale following; Bateman's, Stamford, Lincolnshire, UK (British), October 7, 2017, lot 614; Sotheby's, London, July 3, 2019, lot 403; Vendor: Guy Peppiatt Fine Art Ltd | 1 |
| FUND | M. Lagrenée (French)his sale; Paris, Hôtel Drouot, October 29, 1980, lot 172.; Vendor: Richard Day | 1 |
| FUND | M. Guichardot , his sale, Paris, July 7-10, 1875, lot no. uncertain.; Philippe de Chennevières (French)Lugt 2073, his sale, Paris, Hôtel Drouot, 4 -7 April, 1900, possibly part of lot 95, 528, or 539 (according to Prat, Chennevières exh. cat. 2007).; Hôtel Drouot, Paris , 19 March 1980 (no catalogue, lot number unknown).; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Louise Hasler; Vendor: sale Christie's, London November 29, 1977, lot 169 | 1 |
| FUND | Louis Olry-Roederer; Abraham Simon Wolf Rosenbach (American); Raphael Esmerian (French, born Armenia), his sale, part III, Paris, Palais Galliera, June 6, 1973, part of lot 46.; Vendor: Claus Virch | 1 |
| FUND | Louis Bongard(his mark, not in Lugt) on verso);; Oger & Blanchet (French), June 25, 2020 (lot 15);; Vendor: Benjamin Peronnet | 1 |
| FUND | Lord St. Oswald (British), Nostell Priory, Yorkshire; Bill Thomson, sold at the following; Sotheby's, London, July 6, 2016 (318); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Lord Lascelles, London, 1926; Earl of Harewood; Christie's, London- sale July 6, 1965, lot 143; Private Collection, England; Whitfield Fine Art | 1 |
| FUND | Landesmuseum Joanneum; Heirs of Leo and Helene Hecht, 2003; Dr. Robert Keil (Austrian); Vendor: Dr. Robert Keil (Austrian) | 1 |
| FUND | Kurt Meissner, Zürich (Swiss); British Rail Pension Fund (British); Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Kunstforeningen, Copenhagen (Danish); Vendor: Galerie Sabrina Förster (German) | 1 |
| FUND | Kaye Dowland; M. Goldschmidt | 1 |
| FUND | Kathryn Bache Miller (American)Sale, Christie's London, April 15, 1980, lot 171; Vendor: Yvonne Tan Bunzl | 1 |
| FUND | Karl Ewald Hasse (German) | 1 |
| FUND | Karl & Faber, November 29, 2005, lot 430; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Karl & Faber, November 29, 2005, lot 424; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Karl & Faber, May 30, 2006, lot 115; sale Christie's, London, July 2, 1991, lot 375; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Karl & Faber, December 2, 1971, lots 453/54; Private Collection, South Germany; Karl & Faber, December 4, 2002, lot 193; Karl & Faber, May 30, 2006, lot 345; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Kahn-Dumousset sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, March 29, 2013; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Julius Olivier (German); Dora Olivier (German)(in 1901); Private Collection, Freinsheim(acc. to exh cat Dessau 1930); Private Collection, Berlin(acc to Grote 1938); Vendor: C. G. Boerner LLC, New York (American) | 1 |
| FUND | Julius Böhler, Munich, ca. 1978; private collection, Augsburg (German); Galerie Bassenge (German), June 1, 2012, lot 6272 (as attributed to Adam van Vianen); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Joseph Wopfner (Austrian); possibly Franz Defregger (Austrian); possibly Wilhelm von Borscht (German); sale, Kunsthaus Lempertz, November 19, 2011, lot 1411; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Joseph Marie Vien (French); Pierre Lacour (French), by descent from Vien.; Viel family (French), Louveciennes, by descent.; Vendor: Benoît Choné (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Joseph Kalous; Sotheby's, London, July 5, 2000, lot 296; Vendor: Swann Galleries, Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | Jonathan Richardson Sr. (British); Thomas Hudson (British); Sir Joshua Reynolds (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Jonathan Richardson Sr. (British); P. & D. Colnaghi & Co. | 1 |
| FUND | Jonathan Richardson Sr. (British); Arthur Pond (British); John Barnard (British); Sir Uvedale Price, 1st Baronet (British)- according to annotation on verso old mount.; Sir William Forbes of Pitsligo, 7th Baronet (British, Scottish)- according to Christie's; Christie's, London, July 1, 1986, no. 7, repr.; Sotheby's, London, July 2, 1990, no. 90, repr.; Hazlitt, Gooden & Fox | 1 |
| FUND | Jonathan Richardson Jr. (British)Lugt 2170, 2997; Sir Joshua Reynolds (British)Lugt 2364; Nouveau Drouot, Paris Sale, Paris, salle 6, February 15, 1984, lot 105, repr. as Pietro de Pietri; purchased by Metropolitan Museum | 1 |
| FUND | John Postle Heseltine (British); Henry Oppenheimer (British); Christie's, London, his sale July 10-14m 1936, lot 337; Jacques Bacri; Bacri Frères, Paris; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | John Morton Morris (British) | 1 |
| FUND | John Evelyn (British); by descent J. H. C. Evelyn (British); by descent C. J. A. Evelyn (British); Hon. Sherman Stonor (British); Evelyn sale, Sotheby's, London, March 15, 1966, lot, 3; Private Collection, London; Vendor: Hill-Stone, Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | Johan Quirijn van Regteren Altena (Dutch); Sale Sotheby's, AmsterdamNovember 8, 2000, lot 45; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Jean-Pierre Fromanger, Paris, sold to the followingSold to James Mackinnon, 1995; James Mackinnon Sold to MMA; Vendor: James Mackinnon | 1 |
| FUND | Jean-Jacques Senon (French); his sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, April 2, 2012, lot 13; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Jean Masson Sale, Paris, Hôtel Drouot, November 23, 1927, lot 88; Germain Seligman; Christian Humann sale, New York, Sotheby Parke Bernet, April 30, 1982, lot 59, repr. | 1 |
| FUND | Jean Joubert (French); Christie's, London July 6, 1982, lot 84, repr.; Vendor: Alfred Strölin (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Jean Denis Lempereur (French); Hans Fürstenberg (German); Foundation Fürstenberg-Beaumesnil; Hôtel Drouot, Paris,sale Paris, 11/17/1983 no.126 as Carlo Maratti; John Morton Morris (British)sale Paris, no. 126, as Carlo Maratti, repr. | 1 |
| FUND | Jan van Rymsdyk (British)(ca. 1720–1790) (Lugt 2167); presumably his sale, London, Greenw; John R. Gaines; Trinity Fine Art, at Newhouse Galleries, New York May 5-17, 1994, lot 9; Sotheby's, London, July 3, 1996, lot 70; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Jan Pietersz. Zomer (Dutch); Abraham van Broyel; his sale, Hendrik de Leth (Dutch), Makelaar; Michiel Oudaan, his sale, November 3, 1766, album L, lot 54; Johan Goll van Franckenstein Sr.; Johan Goll van Franckenstein Jr.; possibly owned by his son Pieter Hendrik Goll van Franckenstein , perhaps his sale, Amsterdam, July 1, 1833, album Z, one of no. 45-52; Private Collection, descendants of Oliver de Prat, "Hôtel Albret", Fontainebleau; its sale, Jean-Pierre Osenat Fontainebleau SVV, October 21, 2007, lot 43, (as by an artist of the Dutch School, 17th century); Bob P. Haboldt and Co., Inc. (American); Vendor: Bob P. Haboldt and Co., Inc. (American) | 1 |
| FUND | Jan Pietersz Zoomer(owned the entire series); Jan Goeree (Dutch)(owned the entire series); his sale, Schoemaker, March 17, 1731; Private Collection, Switzerland; Vendor: Jack Kilgore | 1 |
| FUND | Jan Pietersz Zoomer; William Mayor (British); Arthur Ewart Popham (British); Tristram and Sophie Popham(by inheritance from Arthur E. Popham); Sotheby's, London(sale, November 18, 1982, no. 22) | 1 |
| FUND | Jan Pietersz Zoomer; N. G. Stogdon, Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | Jacques Petithory; Louis-Antoine Prat(his mark, P in a circle, not in Lugt); Nouveau Drouot, Paris- salle 2, Dec, 5, 1984, no. 16, repr.; Zangrilli, Brady and Co. | 1 |
| FUND | Jacques Guillaume Legrand (French); sale Bonhams, London, 9 December, 2015, lot 1; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Jacob Theodor Cremer (Dutch); his sale, Sotheby's, Amsterdam, November 17, 1980, lot 34; Lodewijk Arnold Houthakker (Dutch); his sale, Christie's, New York, January 11, 1994, lot 111 | 1 |
| FUND | J.W. Barchman Wuytiers sale, Utrecht, 17 Sept. 1792 (Lugt 4945), lot 76, as "de la Fosse: Diana rescues Iphigenia and gives a deer instead"; black, red and white chalk, 13.50 x 11.50 duim [= ca. 36.45 x 31.05]; buyer unknown for f 7.10 (according to research notes of Michiel Plomp, 10/11/1996); Sotheby's, New YorkParke BernetNovember 21, 1980, lot 38, repr.; Vendor: Lucien Goldschmidt | 1 |
| FUND | J.-A. Duval Le Camus Lugt 1441; Vendor: Alfred Strölin (French) | 1 |
| FUND | J. G. H. Winckler; sale, F.A.C. Prestel, Frankfurt (German), November 10-16, 1920, lot 2032, pl. 5; Franz Koenigs(remaining in family until 2001); sale, Sotheby's, New York, Januay 23, 2001, lot 6; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Irwin Laughlin; Charles E. Slatkin Galleries; Giancarlo Baroni (Italian); Eugene Victor Thaw; Vendor: Christie's, New York | 1 |
| FUND | Iolo Aneurin Williams (British), then by bequest; Daughter of Iolo Aneurin Williams (British); Andrew Clayton-Payne & Co. Ltd.; James Mackinnon; Spink-Leger, London, by 1996, sold to the following; Private Collection, England, until 2017, sold through the following; Andrew Clayton-Payne & Co. Ltd.; Vendor: Andrew Clayton-Payne & Co. Ltd. | 1 |
| FUND | Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 269; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 253Sale Munich, May 5-6, 2003, no. 253; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 249; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 242; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 237; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 226; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 220; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 207; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Hugh Howard (British)(per annotation on mount); Baron Harry Louis Nathan of Churt (British)(per annotation on verso of mount); Sold by P. & D. Colnaghi & Co.in 1972 (as Carpioni); Sale Christie's, New YorkJanuary 24, 2001, lot 97; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Hubert Marignane , French, born in 1921 (Lugt lists Paris and Menton); Nicolas Rauch sale, Geneva, June 11-15, 1960, lot 309, repr., as Nicolas Poussin; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Hôtel Drouot, Paris October 21, 1957, lot 41; Vendor: Morton Morris & Co., London | 1 |
| FUND | Hôtel Drouot, Paris , April 9, 1999, lot 102.; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | His sale "vente M. . . ", Paris, November 11-15, 1784, part of lot 165, with two other drawings also "sur papier blanc et lavés au bistre"; "Le Martyre de Saint Barthelemi, d'après le Calabrois" (according to J.P. Cuzin, BSHAF, 1981).; Vendor: Jacques Petithory | 1 |
| FUND | Henry Scipio Reitlinger (British), British; Sotheby's, London, Dec. 10, 1979, no. 236, recto repr. | 1 |
| FUND | Henry Austin Bruce 1st Baron Aberdare (British); Jeremy Maas; David E. Rust, and by descent; Vendor: Coleman Bancroft LLC | 1 |
| FUND | Heinrich Beckmann; Vendor: Emanuel von Baeyer | 1 |
| FUND | Hazlitt, Gooden & Fox; Count Moriz von Fries (Austrian); Sir Thomas Lawrence (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Hans M. Calmann (British); Lerux; Gabrielle Kopelman (American) | 1 |
| FUND | Hannah Humphrey (British); George Humphrey (British); His widow's sale, Edward Foster's Auction House, London (British), July 13, 1835 (one of lot 398-4790; Humphrey Minto Wilson (British); Mrs. H. Blake Tyler; Her sale Sotheby's, London, July 6, 1964, lot 42; Theodore Besterman (Polish British); His sale, Christie's, London, November 17, 1981, lot 71; Anonymous sale, Christie's, London, November 20, 2003, lot 13; Private Collection, United Kingdom; Vendor: Guy Peppiatt Fine Art Ltd | 1 |
| FUND | Hamburger Kunsthalle; Ingeborg Tremmel; her sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 292; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Guy Peppiatt Fine Art Ltd; Vendor: Guy Peppiatt Fine Art Ltd | 1 |
| FUND | Grandi Collection, Milan; Giovanni Rasini (Italian); Rasini Collection, Switzerland; Thomas Williams Fine Art Ltd., London; Vendor: Thomas Williams Fine Art Ltd., London | 1 |
| FUND | Giuseppe Vallardi (Italian)Vallardi's numbering, "B 198" in graphite on recto and in red chalk on verso.; Alfred Normand (French); Christie's, London, July 9, 1999, lot 85; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Giuseppe Vallardi (Italian); Vendor: Martin Hirschboeck (German) | 1 |
| FUND | Giuseppe Vallardi (Italian); Richard Collins | 1 |
| FUND | Giuseppe Vallardi (Italian)- purchased in London in 1976 | 1 |
| FUND | Giovanni and Giuseppe Simonetta(according to annotation on verso).; Sotheby's, London- Nov. 25, 1971, no. 140, repr.; Yvonne Tan Bunzl; Harold A. E. Day; Sotheby's, London- Dec. 7, 1987, no. 25, repr.; Robert Dance | 1 |
| FUND | Gilles de Noailles , according to vendor; Jean-Pierre Selz (French); Vendor: Lynven, Inc., New York | 1 |
| FUND | Germain Seligman; Christian Humann , his sale, Sotheby Parke Bernet, New York, April 30, 1982, lot 67. | 1 |
| FUND | Gerd Rosen, 25-26 November 1952, no. 1721; Edwin Redslob (German), Berlin; Galerie Bassenge (German), 15 May 1976; Karl & Faber, 7 December 2006, no. 587, repr; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Georges Haumont (French); Hôtel Drouot, Paris, Paris, 3/22/1928, no. 43. repr. | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie de la Scala, Paris, ca. 2006; sale, Piasa, Paris (French), 28 March 2012, lot 86; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German)sale December 3, 2004, no. 5636; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), November 30-December 1, 2006, lot 5512(as by an anonymous Flemish seventeenth-century artist); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), November 30-Dec 1, 2006, lot 5467; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), November 30 - December 1, 2006, lot 5556; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), November 29, 2019 (lot 6602); Christie's, London, April 16, 1991 (lot 202); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), May 27, 2011, lot 6452; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), May 26, 2006, lot 5777; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), May 25, 2006, lot 5543; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), June 8, 2007, lot 6334as by the artist Matthias Scheits; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), December 2, 2005, lot 5750; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), 8 June 2007, lot 6421; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), 28 November 2008, lot 6391; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), 28 November 2008, lot 6367; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), 28 November 2008, lot 6255; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), 28 November 2008, lot 6198; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Galerie Bassenge (German), 27 May, 2016, lot 6655; Vendor: James Mackinnon | 1 |
| FUND | G. Stenman; Sale Christie's, London, December 12, 1985, lot 296; Galerie de Bayser, Parisand Kunsthandel Bellinger (New York, Paris, London, 1994) lot. 4; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris (2001) | 1 |
| FUND | Friedrich Salathé (Swiss)(sold in artist's estate sale, 1913, no. 33); Carl Heumann (German); Carl Heumann's heirs (German); Kornfeld and Klipstein sale June 17, 2004, lot 67; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Frédéric Engel-Gros(1843-1918); his sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, December 19-20, 1921, lot 66(as Daniel Lindtmayer), but possibly still in Engel-Gros's collection in 1925 (see bibliography); René Kieffer(1876-1963), Paris, by 1965; his sale, Hotel George V, ParisMay 29, 1969, lot 49(as Daniel Lindtmayer); Sold August Laube, ZürichJune 3, 1970, lot 1048(as Christoph Murer).; Paul Fischer (Swiss)(1911-1976), Lucerne; Private collection, Switzerland; Sold Koller Auktionen (Swiss), October 1, 2021, lot 3431(as Christoph Murer); to Härb-Nuti, London; Vendor: Martin Graessle Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Franz Goldstein (Austrian); Vendor: Emanuel von Baeyer | 1 |
| FUND | Francis Towne (British), bequeathed to the following; James White (British), received a life interest then bequeated to the following; John Herman Merivale (British), bequeathed to his daughter, the following; Anna Merivale (British), bequeathed to her two nieces, following; Maria Sophie Merivale (British), joint owner by 1915 with the following; Judith Ann Merivale (British), joint owner by 1915 with the preceding; Miss Leonora Francis Arthur (British), purchased from the two preceding, possibly by 1925; Lady Lambert (British), by descent from the preceding; Vendor: Christie's, London | 1 |
| FUND | Francis Towne (British), bequeathed in life interest to the following; James White (British), bequeated to the following; John Herman Merivale (British), bequeathed to his daughter, the following; Anna Merivale (British), bequeathed to her two nieces, following; Maria Sophie Merivale (British), joint owner by 1915 with the following; Judith Ann Merivale (British), joint owner by 1915 with the preceding; Miss Leonora Francis Arthur (British), purchased from the two preceding, poss. 1925; Lady Lambert (British), by descent from the preceding; Vendor: Christie's, London | 1 |
| FUND | Francis G. Hickman (American); Christie's, London03/25-26/63, part of no. 219, as Francesco Vanni; Sotheby's, London, 12/10/79, no. 226, repr. | 1 |
| FUND | Flavia Ormond Fine Arts Limited | 1 |
| FUND | F.A.C. Prestel, Frankfurt (German), 1908 or later; Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 211; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Eugène Rodrigues his collection sale, Hotel Drouot, Paris, November 28-29, 1928, lot 141; Beaussant & Lefèvre (French)Sale, Paris, March 24, 1999, lot 16; [bought by the Galerie de Bayser, Paris]; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Ernst Heinrich Ehlers (German); Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 236; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Emmanuel Moatti | 1 |
| FUND | Emile Norblin , Norblin sale, Paris, March 16-17, 1860, Supplément no. 16, "La conversation Espagnole. - La première pensée du tableau qui a été gravé par Beauvarlet - Beau dessin exécuté à la plume, au bistre."; D.-G. d'Arozarena , Arozarena sale, Paris, May 29, 1861, no. 92, "La Conversation espagnole . . . Collection Norblin"; Edmond de Goncourt (French)Lugt 1089; Goncourt sale, Paris, February 15-17, 1897, lot 332.; de Jonghe; Vendor: Jean Cailleux (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Edwin S. Chapin, New York (American)- according to vendor - purchased in N.Y., 1975 | 1 |
| FUND | Edwin Redslob (German); sale, Hauswedell & Nolte, Hamburg (German), June 6, 2012, lot 1; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Edward Vernon Utterson (British); Alcide Donnadieu | 1 |
| FUND | Earl of Ellesmere (British); Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd.; Christie's, London, December 15, 1950, lot 20 (18 gs. to Colnaghi); P. & D. Colnaghi & Co.; Spink-Leger Pictures, London; Christie's, London, November 14, 2002, lot 65; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Duvivier family , From an album assembled by the family in the late 18th century and dispersed in 1987; sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, October 29, 1987, part of lot 60 (as Vierge à l'Enfant, "entourage d'Antoine Coypel"); Christie's, London , July 5, 1988, lot 118; Vendor: Morton Morris & Co., London | 1 |
| FUND | Duvivier family , From an album assembled by the family in the late 18th century and dispersed in 1987; sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, October 29, 1987, part of lot 57 as "école française XVIIe siècle (entourage d'Antoine Coypel), étude d'un général antique."; Christie's, London July 4, 1989, lot 119, repr.; Vendor: Hazlitt, Gooden & Fox | 1 |
| FUND | Dr. Carl Robert Rudolf; his sale, Sotheby's, London, July 4, 1977, part of lot 84(as by a late sixteenth-century Netherlandish artist, possibly Cornelis Cornelisz. van Haarlem); sale, Sotheby's, New York, January 13, 1989, part of lot 80(as by a late sixteenth-century Haarlem artist, possibly Cornelis Cornelisz. van Haarlem); Edmund P. Pillsbury; Harari & Johns, London, 1990; Vendor: Compagnie des Beaux-Arts Ltd. (Swiss) | 1 |
| FUND | Dr. Carl Robert Rudolf, (his collector's mark on the old mount; Lugt 2811b); Rudolf sale, Sotheby's, London, July 4, 1977, part of lot. 84; Edmund P. Pillsbury; on sale at Harari & Johns, London(November 30 - December 14, 1990), lot. 14; Edoardo Testori (Italian)(according to Goguel 2001: see bibliography); Vendor: Purchased from Compagnie des Beaux-Arts Ltd. (Swiss) (Switzerland) | 1 |
| FUND | Dr. Anton Schrafl; Vendor: Christie's, London December 9, 1982, lot 21 | 1 |
| FUND | Dr. A. Glaser, Basel; Dr. Willi Raeber, Basel; Galerie Kornfeld sale, June 17, 2004, lot 122; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Dorotheum, March 19, 2002, lot 36; Vendor: Emanuel von Baeyer | 1 |
| FUND | Don Gaspar Méndez de Haro y Guzmán, 7th Marquès del Carpio (Spanish), Marchese del Carpio e Helice, 1687 [sheet 92, drawing no. 86]; sale, Christie's, London, March 20, 1973, lot 23; Chiltern Art Gallery, London; Mondial Fine Arts Ltd.; Vendor: Mondial Fine Arts Ltd. | 1 |
| FUND | Descendants of the artist(acc. to Villa Grisebach); Villa Grisebach Auktionen, Berlin, November 30, 2001, lot 1786B (bought in); Galerie Bassenge (German), Nov 20-Dec 1, 2006, lot 5800; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Descendants of the artist; probably Kunsthaus Lempertz, November 17, 2001, lot 1276; Vendor: Joseph Fach | 1 |
| FUND | Descendants of Eduard Julius Friedrich Bendemann (German); Galerie Bassenge (German), December 1, 2006, lot 5640; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Delbergue Cormont sale, Paris, May 31, 1882, no. 12 bis, mistakenly as "La Sainte Vierge dans les Cieux, adorée par les saints"; Hippolyte-Alexandre-Gabriel-Walter Destailleur (French)Destailleur sale, Paris, May 19-23, 1896, part of no. 734.; Hôtel Drouot, Paris May 16-17, 1898, part of no. 63.; Vendor: Galerie Cailleux, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Delbergue Cormont Delbergue Cormont sale, Paris, May 31, 1882, no. 12, mistakenly as "L'Assomption de la Sainte Vierge"; Hippolyte-Alexandre-Gabriel-Walter Destailleur (French)Destailleur sale, Paris, May 19-23, 1896, part of no. 734.; Hôtel Drouot, Paris May 16-17, 1898, part of no. 63.; Vendor: Galerie Cailleux, Paris , Paris | 1 |
| FUND | David Jones; Frederick J. Cummings (American); Vendor: Brady, W. M. and Co., Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | David Elissett (British); Vendor: Elmar W. Seibel (American) | 1 |
| FUND | Count Gregory Serguevitch Strogonoff (Russian)(Lugt 550); Duke Roberto Ferretti, Conte di Castelferretti (Italian); Christie's, London, July 2, 1996, Lot 48 (£23,000); Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Count Gregory Serguevitch Strogonoff (Russian); Walter Schrott; Anton Schmid (Austrian); Galerie Arnoldi-Livie (German) | 1 |
| FUND | Count Christian Johan Frederik Ahlefeldt Laurvig (Danish); his descendants; sale, Winkel & Magnussen (Danish), November 2-7, 1939, lot 726; sale, Bruun Rasmussen Bredgade, Copenhagen, February 29, 2012, lot 827/164; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Cornelius Varley (British), and by descent until ca. 1990; Private Collection, United Kingdom, until 2004; Vendor: Lowell Libson Ltd. (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Cornelis Hofstede de Groot (Dutch); his sale C. G. Boerner, Leipzig (German)Nov. 4, 1931, lot 238, pl. xxi; C. Rupp; Sale, Sotheby's, New YorkJanuary 23, 2001, lot 150; With Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Comte André Gaspard Parfait de Bizemont Prunelé (French)Lugt 128; Vendor: Jill Newhouse (American) | 1 |
| FUND | Collection of Earls Spencer (British)Lugt 1531; sale, London, T. Philipe, June 10-17, 1811, no. 433, "Monks administering the sacrament to the wounded in battle - masterly black chalk"; William Esdaile (British)Lugt 2617; sale, London, Christie's, June 18-25, 1840, part of lot 1205, "St. Ambrose visiting the sick at Milan, black chalk; and two, by J. Bourdon."; Dr. Carl Robert Rudolf sale, London, Sotheby's, May 29, 1975, lot 2, pl. 11; Vendor: Colnaghi, New York | 1 |
| FUND | Collection of Earls Spencer (British); Sotheby's, New York, January 20, 1982, no. 36January 20, 1982 sale, no. 36, repr., as Antoine Coypel, Biblical Scene, purchased by the MMA. | 1 |
| FUND | collection De Vyss; Eva Dencker-Winkler (Swiss), in 1987; sale, Sotheby's, New York, January 23, 2001, lot 112; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Claudine Bouzonnet Stella (French); Michel de Masso , by descent; Gaetano Minossi Romano; Thomas Talbot; Lady Beythswood , by descent; Christopher Methuen-Campbell (British), 1974; Christie's, New York , January 13, 1987, lot 106 (as "property of a gentleman") | 1 |
| FUND | Christina, Queen of Sweden (Swedish)(?); Decio Cardinal Azzolini; Marchese Pompeo Azzolini; Prince Livio Odescalchi; Prince Ladislao Odescalchi(Sixth drawing in the Odescalchi Album A)(according to Mahoney); Galerie Bassenge (German) | 1 |
| FUND | Christina, Queen of Sweden (Swedish)(?); Decio Cardinal Azzolini; Marchese Pompeo Azzolini; Prince Livio Odescalchi; Prince Ladislao Odescalchi(first drawing in Odescalchi Album A)(according to Mahoney); Galerie Bassenge (German) | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, Paris, December 16, 2005, lot 228Sale December 16, 2005, lot 228; Vendor: Galerie Nathalie Motte Masselink (French) | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, Paris, 15 Nov 06, lot 204; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, New York, January 24, 2006, lot 120; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, New York, January 24, 2006, lot 119; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, New York, January 24, 2006, lot 117; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, LondonMarch 26-27, 1974, no.46.; Herman Shickman Gallery | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, London, sale December 11, 1979, no. 55 (repr.); Yvonne Tan Bunzl | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, London, June 28, 1940, lot 22, bought by the following; Humphrey Minto Wilson (British); Bonhams, Knightsbridge, April 17, 2012, lot 100; Christie's, London, July 10, 2014, lot 194; Vendor: James Mackinnon | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, London, June 28, 1940, lot 22, bought by the following; Humphrey Minto Wilson (British); Bonhams, Knightsbridge, April 17, 2012 (lot 100); Christie's, London, July 10, 2014, lot 194; Vendor: James Mackinnon | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, London, July 1, 1969, no. 21Sale, London, Christie's, July 1, 1969, no. 21; purchased for the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York in 1979. | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, London, 4 July 1978, lot 62; Sotheby's, London, 4 July 2012, lot 35; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, London July 2, 1996, lot 217.; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, London July 10, 2001, lot 107; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Christie's, London , November 27, 1973, lot 276, purchased by Stein.; Vendor: Adolphe Stein | 1 |
| FUND | Chrisitan Gottfried L. Matthes (German); Galerie Bassenge (German), December 1, 2005, lot 5635; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Charles Gasc (French); Kaïeman His sale, Catalogue de la Belle et Riche Collection de Dessins Anciens, Paris, April 26, 1858 - May 1, 1858. lot no. 1340. p. 90. "Paysage avec ruines, traité dans le style de Claude Lorrain. - Lavé à l'encre."; Philippe de Chennevières (French)Lugt 2072; Chennevières sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, April 4-7, 1900, part of no. 6 ("Ruines d'un temple antique au bord d'un lac. -Paysages. Trois dessins à la plume lavis d'encre de chine"). sold to Grosjean for 7 francs, according to Prat, Chennevières exh. cat. 2007.; Pierre Guéraud , his sale, Enghein-les-Bains, Hôtel des ventes, Nov. 20, 1977, lot 16.; Paul Prouté, Paris (French), in 1980.; Galerie de Bayser, Paris , sold for 12,000 F. | 1 |
| FUND | Cavaliere Francesco Maria Niccolò Gabburri (Italian); William Kent (British)(?); Sotheby's, London Private collection, Ireland; sale, Sotheby's London, November 20, 1957. | 1 |
| FUND | Carle (Charles André) Vanloo (French), his sale, Paris, September 12, 1765, part of lot 11 (seven drawings).; Jacques Augustin de Silvestre (French)Silvestre sale, Paris, February 28- March 25, 1811, part of lot 558.; Marius Paulme; Private Collection, Paris , (possibly Deuillet ? according to Sahut and Rosenberg), sale, Paris, Galerie Georges Petit, April 27, 1932, lot 39.; Private Collection, Paris , (possibly Cotnareanu ? according to Sahut and Rosenberg), sale, Paris, Palais Galliera, Dec. 14, 1960, lot 9.; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Carle (Charles André) Vanloo (French), his sale, Paris, September 12, 1765, part of lot 11 (seven drawings); Jacques Augustin de Silvestre (French), his sale, Paris, February 28 - March 25, 1811, lot no. 558.; Marius Paulme; Private Collection, Paris , (possibly Deuillet ? according to Sahut and Rosenberg), sale, Paris, Galerie Georges Petit, April 27, 1932, lot 39.; Private Collection, Paris , (possibly Cotnareanu ? according to Sahut and Rosenberg), sale, Paris, Palais Galliera, Dec. 14, 1960, lot 9.; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Carl Heumann (German)Chemnitz, Germany; Carl Heumann's heirs (German); Kornfeld and Klipstein, June 17, 2004, lot 4; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Carl Heumann (German); Stuttgarter Kunstkabinett, November 1957; Private Collection, Munich, ca. 1991; Galerie Bassenge (German), June 4, 2010, lot 6456; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Carl Heumann (German); Carl Heumann's heirs (German); Kornfeld and Klipstein, June 17, 2004, lot 19; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Carl Heumann (German); Carl Heumann's heirs (German); Kornfeld and Klipstein sale June 17, 2004, lot 78; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Carl Heumann (German); Carl Heumann's heirs (German); Kornfeld and Klipstein Sale June 17, 2004, lot 40; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Carel Emil Duits; Galerie Bassenge (German), November 25, 2011, lot 6237; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | C. G. Boerner, Dusseldorf (German); Galerie Bassenge (German), November 25, 2011, lot 6207 (as by an Augsburg artist c. 1600); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Brian Sewell (British); Vendor: Brian Sewell (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Borghese-Sagredo Album(original mounting); Zaccaria Sagredo (Italian); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Borghese-Sagredo Album(inscription on verso of old mount, S.F. no: 18); Zaccaria Sagredo (Italian); Nissman, Abromson and Co. | 1 |
| FUND | Borghese-Sagredo Album; Zaccaria Sagredo (Italian); Private Collection, Lyon; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Boguslaw Jolles, Dresden and Vienna (German); Ingeborg Tremmel; sale, Ketterer Kunst, Munich, May 5-6, 2003, lot 216; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Bill Thomson, sold at the following; Sotheby's, London, July 6, 2016 (318); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Benno Geiger (German)(according to note on photo in Witt Library); Sotheby's, London- sale December 7-10, 1920, part of no. 305(Property of a Gentleman, sold as a lot with three other drawings by Solimena. The copy of the catalogue in the MMA Library has the price of lot no. 305 as 10 English pound and the buyer as Reader written in the border.); Christie's, London- sale June 25, 1974, no. 194, repr.; Yvonne Tan Bunzl | 1 |
| FUND | Benedetto Gennari (Italian)('Casa Gennari' mount); Cesare Gennari (Italian); Possibly Francesco Forni; John Bouverie (British); Possibly Honorable Edward Bouverie (British); Charles Noel, 1st Earl of Gainsborough (British); Smithson and Williams | 1 |
| FUND | Beaussant & Lefèvre (French), 07 March 2012, lot 39; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Beaussant & Lefèvre (French), 07 March 2012, lot 38; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Beaussant & Lefèvre (French), 07 March 2012, lot 35; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Beaussant & Lefèvre (French), 07 March 2012, lot 33; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | AuctionArt - Rémy Le Fur & Associés, 27 April 2012, lot 119; Galerie Cailleux, Paris; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Artcurial, ParisMarch 23, 2017 (lot 46); Artcurial, ParisDecember 13, 2005 (lot 28); Hotel George V, ParisDecember 9, 1981 (lot 48); Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel | 1 |
| FUND | Archduke Friedrich von Habsburg-Lothringen (Austrian); Vendor: Dr. Robert Keil (Austrian) | 1 |
| FUND | Antoine Rutgers (The inscription in the lower left corner, Andrea Sacchi ft. 1625, is by A. Rutgers) (Michiel Plomp, March 1997); v.d. Schley...Yver, Amsterdam, Rutgers sale, Dec 1, 1778(Lugt 2920) F 348 (Michiel Plomp, March 1997); Sir Thomas Lawrence (British)? (according to inscription on verso; no mark); possibly Christie's, London, sale June 29, 1971, no. 135("A. Sacchi, The Drunkenness of Noah, inscribed on the mount 'nel: Pal: di Barberini Andrea Sacchi' - red chalk - framed, 7-1/4 x 9-3/4 in. (184 x 248 mm)).; Armando Neerman | 1 |
| FUND | Antoine Augustin Renouard (French)his sale, Paris, November 20- December 20, 1854, acquired as part of lot 2420 for 400 francs; Baron James de Rothschild (French)(according to Bocher in 1882); Private collection, France; Galerie de Bayser, Paris; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Anonymous sale, Sotheby's, London, November 11, 1965, part of lot 17; Bernard Houthakker (Dutch), Master Drawings, 1966, cat. 51; Saam Nijstad and Lily Nijstad-Einhorn (Dutch), The Hague; their sale, Sotheby's, Amsterdam, May 19, 2004, lot 118; Otto Naumann, Ltd.; his sale, Sotheby's, New York, January 25, 2007, lot 116; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Anonymous sale, Sotheby's, London, April 19, 1992, lot 28, bought by the following; Private Collection, United Kingdom, sold by "a gentleman" at the following; Sale, Sotheby's, London, December 4, 2008, lot 117; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Anonymous sale, Phillips Auctioneers LLC, April 18, 1988, lot 15, bought by the following; Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd., in 1989, sold to the following; Monsieur and Madame Gérald Bauer, sold at the following; Christie's, London, January 22, 2003, lot 16; Thomas Agnew & Sons, Ltd.; W.S Fine Art Ltd. / Andrew Wyld (British), in 2006; Private Collection, England, until 2017; Vendor: Andrew Clayton-Payne & Co. Ltd. | 1 |
| FUND | Anna Maria Edelstein; Succi Ltd. | 1 |
| FUND | ANAF, Lyons, Hotel des Ventes (French), 02 Jul 02, lot 107lot 107; Hill-Stone, Inc.; Vendor: Hill-Stone, Inc. | 1 |
| FUND | an unidentified Christie's sale, where acquired by Stanley Jernow; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | Alfred Morrison (British); Christie's, London, Jan. 28, 1899 (15); Leggatt Brothers (British); Phillips, London (British), October 31, 1983 (88); Martyn Gregory, London, in 1984; Christie's, London, November 13, 1992 (88), bought in; Martyn Gregory, London, in 2015; Vendor: Martyn Gregory, London | 1 |
| FUND | Alfred Baldwin (British)[purchased 1867 or after; owned by 1873]; Chris Beetles, London (British), in March 2002; Christopher Cone (British); his sale; Sotheby's, London, May 22, 2014, lot 134; Stephen Ongpin Fine Art (British); Vendor: Stephen Ongpin Fine Art (British) | 1 |
| FUND | Adrian Ward-Jackson(by 1984); Lynven, Inc., New York; Vendor: Lynven, Inc., New York | 1 |
| FUND | Adolphe Stein-according to dealer | 1 |
| FUND | Achille de Clemente (Italian); Sotheby's, London, July 8, 1998, lot 16; Sotheby's, London, July 11, 2001, lot 2 as Giuliano Bugiardini; Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel, Munich; Vendor: Katrin Bellinger Kunsthandel , Munich | 1 |
| FUND | according to annotation on the verso of drawing, Sir Joshua Reynolds (British); Marquis Jean de Bailleul (French); Private Collection, Paris; Vendor: Galerie de Bayser, Paris | 1 |
| FUND | Abbott and Holder Ltd. (British); Vendor: Pia Gallo | 1 |
| FUND | Vendor: C. G. Boerner LLC, New York (American) | 1 |
| FUND | Richard Mills (British); Christie's, London, April 13, 1908, lot 3; 25 gs., bought by the following; Gooden & Fox, Ltd., London; Roberto Longhi; Pietro Maria Bardi; Christie's, London, June 9, 2004, lot 17; Vendor: Christie's, London , 13 July 2016, lot 115 | 1 |
| FUND | Private collector (descendant of Benjamin West), sold at the following; Sotheby's, London, April 10, 1997, lot 26; Vendor: Christie's, London , July 5, 2016, lot 71 | 1 |
| FUND | Private collection, France; Hôtel Drouot, ParisMarch 30, 1989, lot 168; Hazlitt, Gooden & Fox; Vendor: Hazlitt, Gooden & Fox | 1 |
| FUND | possibly Johannes Hermanus Henricus Leonhardt (Dutch); probably his son, George Leonhardt (Dutch); his son, George J.G. Leonhardt (Dutch); hos wife, G.E.A.M. Leonhardt-Pilz von Wernhof (Dutch); her sale, Christie's, Amsterdam, November 20, 1989, lot 220; Vendor: Bob P. Haboldt and Co., Inc. (American) | 1 |
| FUND | John Fitchett Marsh His mark, Lugt 1455, appeared on old mat of the drawing, according to Colnaghi cat.; sale, Milan, Finarte Milano, 30 November 1982, no. 136, repr.; Vendor: P. & D. Colnaghi & Co. | 1 |
| FUND | A. M. Legentil-Marcotte | 1 |
| FUND Total | 611 |
